Úrvalsdeild Men's Domestic All-First Team

The Úrvalsdeild karla Domestic All-First Team is an annual Úrvalsdeild karla honor bestowed on the best domestic players in the league following every season. It has been awarded since the 1987-88 season.^[1]

All-time award winners

*	Elected to the National Olympic and Sports Association of Iceland Hall of Fame
Player (X)	Denotes the number of times the player has been selected
Player (in bold text)	Indicates the player who won the Úrvalsdeild karla Domestic Player of the Year in the same year[a]

Hlynur Bæringsson has been selected to the Domestic All-First team 10 times.

Season	First team
	Players	Teams
1987-88	Guðmundur Bragason	Grindavík
	Guðni Guðnason	KR
	Jón Kr. Gíslason	Keflavík
	Pálmar Sigurðsson	Haukar
	Valur Ingimundarson	Njarðvík
1988-89	Guðmundur Bragason (2)	Grindavík
	Jón Kr. Gíslason (2)	Keflavík
	Teitur Örlygsson	Njarðvík
	Tómas Holton	Valur
	Valur Ingimundarson (2)	Tindastóll
1989-90	Guðjón Skúlason	Keflavík
	Jón Kr. Gíslason (3)	Keflavík
	Páll Kolbeinsson	KR
	Teitur Örlygsson (2)	Njarðvík
	Valur Ingimundarson (3)	Tindastóll
1990-91	Falur Harðarson	Keflavík
	Jón Kr. Gíslason (4)	Keflavík
	Magnús Matthíasson	Valur
	Teitur Örlygsson (3)	Njarðvík
	Valur Ingimundarson (4)	Tindastóll
1991-92	Guðmundur Bragason (3)	Grindavík
	Jón Kr. Gíslason (5)	Keflavík
	Pétur Guðmundsson*	Tindastóll
	Teitur Örlygsson (4)	Njarðvík
	Valur Ingimundarson (5)	Tindastóll
1992-93	Birgir Mikaelsson	Skallagrímur
	Guðmundur Bragason (4)	Grindavík
	Jón Kr. Gíslason (6)	Keflavík
	Magnús Matthíasson (2)	Valur
	Teitur Örlygsson (5)	Njarðvík
1993-94	Davíð Grissom	KR
	Guðmundur Bragason (5)	Grindavík
	Hjörtur Harðarson	Grindavík
	Jón Kr. Gíslason (7)	Keflavík
	Teitur Örlygsson (6)	Njarðvík
1994-95	Falur Harðarson (2)	KR
	Guðmundur Bragason (6)	Grindavík
	Herbert Arnarson	ÍR
	Kristinn Friðriksson	Þór Akureyri
	Teitur Örlygsson (7)	Njarðvík
1995-96	Guðmundur Bragason (7)	Grindavík
	Herbert Arnarson (2)	ÍR
	Hermann Hauksson	KR
	Jón Arnar Ingvarsson	Haukar
	Teitur Örlygsson (8)	Njarðvík
1996-97	Albert Óskarsson	Keflavík
	Alexander Ermolinskij	ÍA
	Falur Harðarson (3)	Keflavík
	Helgi Jónas Guðfinnsson	Grindavík
	Hermann Hauksson (2)	KR
1997-98	Falur Harðarson (4)	Keflavík
	Friðrik Stefánsson	KFÍ
	Helgi Jónas Guðfinnsson (2)	Grindavík
	Sigfús Gizurarson	Haukar
	Teitur Örlygsson (9)	Njarðvík
1998-99	Dagur Þórisson	ÍA
	Falur Harðarson (5)	Keflavík
	Friðrik Ragnarsson	Njarðvík
	Herbert Arnarson (3)	Grindavík
	Teitur Örlygsson (10)	Njarðvík
1999-00	Fannar Ólafsson	KR
	Friðrik Stefánsson (2)	Njarðvík
	Ólafur Jón Ormsson	KR
	Svavar Birgisson	Tindastóll
	Teitur Örlygsson (11)	Njarðvík
2000-01	Eiríkur Önundarson	ÍR
	Jón Arnór Stefánsson	KR
	Logi Gunnarsson	Njarðvík
	Óðinn Ásgeirsson	Þór Akureyri
	Ólafur Jón Ormsson (2)	KR
2001-02	Friðrik Stefánsson (3)	Njarðvík
	Hlynur Bæringsson	Skallagrímur
	Jón Arnór Stefánsson (2)	KR
	Óðinn Ásgeirsson (2)	Þór Akureyri
	Pálmi Freyr Sigurgeirsson	Breiðablik
2002-03	Damon Johnson	Keflavík
	Eiríkur Önundarson (2)	ÍR
	Helgi Jónas Guðfinnsson (3)	Grindavík
	Hlynur Bæringsson (2)	Snæfell
	Páll Axel Vilbergsson	Grindavík
	Páll Kristinsson	Njarðvík
2003-04	Hlynur Bæringsson (3)	Snæfell
	Lárus Jónsson	Hamar
	Páll Axel Vilbergsson (2)	Grindavík
	Páll Kristinsson (2)	Njarðvík
	Pálmi Freyr Sigurgeirsson (2)	Breiðablik
2004-05	Friðrik Stefánsson (4)	Njarðvík
	Hlynur Bæringsson (4)	Snæfell
	Magnús Þór Gunnarsson	Keflavík
	Sigurður Þorvaldsson	Snæfell
	Sævar Ingi Haraldsson	Haukar
2005-06	Fannar Ólafsson (2)	KR
	Friðrik Stefánsson (5)	Njarðvík
	Ingvaldur Magni Hafsteinsson	Snæfell
	Magnús Þór Gunnarsson (2)	Keflavík
	Páll Axel Vilbergsson (3)	Grindavík
2006-07	Brenton Birmingham	Njarðvík
	Friðrik Stefánsson (6)	Njarðvík
	Hlynur Bæringsson (5)	Snæfell
	Páll Axel Vilbergsson (4)	Grindavík
	Sigurður Þorvaldsson	Snæfell
2007-08	Brenton Birmingham	Njarðvík
	Hlynur Bæringsson (6)	Snæfell
	Hreggviður Magnússon	ÍR
	Páll Axel Vilbergsson (5)	Grindavík
	Sveinbjörn Claessen	ÍR
2008-09	Brenton Birmingham	Njarðvík
	Jakob Örn Sigurðarson	KR
	Jón Arnór Stefánsson (3)	KR
	Sigurður Gunnar Þorsteinsson	Keflavík
	Sigurður Þorvaldsson	Snæfell
2009-10	Brynjar Þór Björnsson	KR
	Hlynur Bæringsson (7)	Snæfell
	Hörður Vilhjálmsson	Keflavík
	Páll Axel Vilbergsson (6)	Grindavík
	Sigurður Þorvaldsson	Snæfell
2010-11	Brynjar Þór Björnsson	KR
	Hörður Vilhjálmsson (2)	Keflavík
	Jón Ólafur Jónsson	Snæfell
	Pavel Ermolinskij	KR
	Sigurður Gunnar Þorsteinsson (2)	Keflavík
2011-12	Finnur Atli Magnússon	KR
	Jón Ólafur Jónsson (2)	Snæfell
	Justin Shouse	Stjarnan
	Magnús Þór Gunnarsson (3)	Keflavík
	Sigurður Gunnar Þorsteinsson (3)	Grindavík
2012-13	Elvar Már Friðriksson	Njarðvík
	Jóhann Árni Ólafsson	Grindavík
	Jón Ólafur Jónsson (3)	Snæfell
	Justin Shouse (2)	Stjarnan
	Sigurður Gunnar Þorsteinsson (4)	Grindavík
2013-14	Elvar Már Friðriksson (2)	Njarðvík
	Helgi Már Magnússon	KR
	Martin Hermannsson	KR
	Pavel Ermolinskij (2)	KR
	Ragnar Ágúst Nathanaelsson	Þór Þorlákshöfn
2014-15	Darrel Lewis	Tindastóll
	Grétar Ingi Erlendsson	Þór Þorlákshöfn
	Helgi Már Magnússon (2)	KR
	Logi Gunnarsson (2)	Njarðvík
	Pavel Ermolinskij (3)	KR
2015-16	Haukur Helgi Pálsson	Njarðvík
	Helgi Már Magnússon (3)	KR
	Kári Jónsson	Haukar
	Pavel Ermolinskij (4)	KR
	Ragnar Ágúst Nathanaelsson (2)	Þór Þorlákshöfn
2016-17	Matthías Orri Sigurðarson	ÍR
	Logi Gunnarsson (3)	Njarðvík
	Jón Arnór Stefánsson (4)	KR
	Ólafur Ólafsson	Grindavík
	Hlynur Bæringsson (8)	Stjarnan
2017-18[2]	Pétur Rúnar Birgisson	Tindastóll
	Sigtryggur Arnar Björnsson	Tindastóll
	Kári Jónsson (2)	Haukar
	Kristófer Acox	KR
	Hlynur Bæringsson (9)	Stjarnan
2018-19[3]	Matthías Orri Sigurðarson (2)	ÍR
	Ægir Steinarsson	Stjarnan
	Kristófer Acox (2)	KR
	Hlynur Bæringsson (10)	Stjarnan
	Sigurður Þorsteinsson (5)	ÍR
2020-21[4]	Hörður Axel Vilhjálmsson (3)	Keflavík
	Ægir Steinarsson (2)	Stjarnan
	Styrmir Snær Þrastarson	Þór Þorlákshöfn
	Kristófer Acox (3)	Valur
	Sigurður Þorsteinsson (6)	Höttur
2021-22	Hilmar Pétursson	Breiðablik
	Sigtryggur Arnar Björnsson (2)	Tindastóll
	Ólafur Ólafsson (2)	Grindavík
	Kristófer Acox (4)	Valur
	Sigurður Þorsteinsson (7)	Höttur
2022-23[5]	Kári Jónsson (3)	Valur
	Sigtryggur Arnar Björnsson (3)	Tindastóll
	Ólafur Ólafsson (3)	Grindavík
	Styrmir Snær Þrastarson (2)	Þór Þorlákshöfn
	Kristófer Acox (5)	Valur
2023-24[6]	Kristinn Pálsson	Valur
	Þórir Þorbjarnarson	Tindastóll
	Ægir Steinarsson (3)	Stjarnan
	Tómas Valur Þrastarson	Þór Þorlákshöfn
	Kristófer Acox (6)	Valur
2024-25[7]	Ægir Steinarsson (4)	Stjarnan
	Hilmar Smári Henningsson	Stjarnan
	Þórir Þorbjarnarson (2)	KR
	Kristinn Pálsson (2)	Valur
	Haukur Helgi Pálsson (2)	Álftanes