# | Score | Team | Goalscorer (assist(s)) | Time |
First period |
| | Montreal | Goaltender in: Worsley | 0:00 |
| | All-Stars | Goaltender in: Hall | 0:00 |
| 0–0 | All-Stars | Penalty: Gadsby | 0:48 |
| 0–0 | Montreal | Goaltender out: Worsley Goaltender in: Hodge | 5:00 |
| 0–0 | Montreal | Penalty: Beliveau | 7:13 |
| 0–0 | Montreal | Penalty: Harris | 9:48 |
| 0–0 | Montreal | Goaltender out: Hodge Goaltender in: Worsley | 9:48 |
| 0–0 | Montreal | Penalty: Larose | 13:27 |
| 0–0 | Montreal | Goaltender out: Worsley Goaltender in: Hodge | 14:26 |
| 0–0 | All-Stars | Penalty: Pronovost | 16:08 |
| 0–0 | Montreal | Penalty: Harris | 16:33 |
Second period |
| 0–2 | Montreal | Goaltender out: Hodge Goaltender in: Worsley | 0:00 |
| | Montreal | Goaltender out: Worsley Goaltender in: Hodge | 5:14 |
1 | 0–1 | Montreal | Goal: Beliveau (Duff, Rousseau) | 6:48 |
2 | 0–2 | Montreal | Goal: Laperriere (Backstrom, Larose) | 11:00 |
| 0–2 | Montreal | Goaltender out: Hodge Goaltender in: Worsley | 11:00 |
3 | 1–2 | All-Stars | Goal: Ullman (Hull, Howe) | 12:40 |
| 1–2 | Montreal | Penalty: Balon | 16:31 |
| 1–2 | Montreal | Goaltender out: Worsley Goaltender in: Hodge | 16:31 |
4 | 2–2 | All-Stars | Goal: Hull (Howe, Oliver) (PPG) | 16:34 |
5 | 3–2 | All-Stars | Goal: Howe (Ullman, Baun) | 19:19 |
Third period |
| 3–2 | Montreal | Goaltender out: Hodge Goaltender in: Worsley | 0:00 |
| 3–2 | Montreal | Goaltender out: Worsley Goaltender in: Hodge | 5:45 |
| 3–2 | All-Stars | Penalty: Ellis | 6:20 |
6 | 4–2 | All-Stars | Goal: Bucyk (Gadsby, Oliver) | 10:52 |
| 4–2 | Montreal | Goaltender out: Hodge Goaltender in: Worsley | 11:05 |
| 4–2 | Montreal | Penalty: Ferguson | 11:57 |
| 4–2 | All-Stars | Penalty: Howell | 14:31 |
| 4–2 | Montreal | Goaltender out: Worsley Goaltender in: Hodge | 15:44 |
| 4–2 | All-Stars | Penalty: Howell | 18:31 |
7 | 5–2 | All-Stars | Goal: Howe (unassisted) (SHG) | 18:39 |
Goaltenders |
- Montreal : Worsley (30:46 minutes, 1 goal), Hodge (29:14 minutes, 4 goals).
- All-Stars: Hall (60:00 minutes, 2 goals)
|
Shots on goal |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | T |
Montreal Canadiens | 13 | 14 | 15 | 41 |
NHL All-Stars | 8 | 12 | 5 | 25 |
|
Officials |
- Referee: Art Skov
- Linesmen: Neil Armstrong, Matt Pavelich
|