| Offense |
| Position |
First team |
Second team |
| Quarterback |
Rich Gannon, Oakland Raiders (AP, PFWA, TSN) |
Peyton Manning, Indianapolis Colts (AP-2) |
| Running back |
Marshall Faulk, St. Louis Rams (AP, PFWA, TSN) Eddie George, Tennessee Titans (AP, PFWA) Edgerrin James, Indianapolis Colts (TSN) |
Robert Smith, Minnesota Vikings (AP-2) Edgerrin James, Indianapolis Colts (AP-2) |
| Wide receiver |
Randy Moss, Minnesota Vikings (AP, PFWA, TSN) Marvin Harrison, Indianapolis Colts (PFWA, TSN) Terrell Owens, San Francisco 49ers (AP) |
Rod Smith, Denver Broncos (AP-2) Marvin Harrison, Indianapolis Colts (AP-2) |
| Tight end |
Tony Gonzalez, Kansas City Chiefs (AP, PFWA, TSN) |
Frank Wycheck, Tennessee Titans (AP-2t) Chad Lewis, Philadelphia Eagles (AP-2t) |
| Tackle |
Jonathan Ogden, Baltimore Ravens (AP, PFWA, TSN) Willie Roaf, New Orleans Saints (PFWA) Orlando Pace, St. Louis Rams (TSN) Kyle Turley, New Orleans Saints (AP) |
Willie Roaf, New Orleans Saints (AP-2) Orlando Pace, St. Louis Rams (AP-2) |
| Guard |
Larry Allen, Dallas Cowboys (AP, PFWA, TSN) Bruce Matthews, Tennessee Titans (AP, PFWA, TSN) |
Ruben Brown, Buffalo Bills (AP-2) Steve Wisniewski, Oakland Raiders (AP-2) |
| Center |
Tom Nalen, Denver Broncos (AP, TSN) Kevin Mawae, New York Jets (PFWA) |
Kevin Mawae, New York Jets (AP-2) |
| Special teams |
| Position |
First team |
Second team |
| Kicker |
Matt Stover, Baltimore Ravens (AP, PFWA, TSN) |
Martín Gramática, Tampa Bay Buccaneers (AP-2) |
| Punter |
Shane Lechler, Oakland Raiders (AP, TSN) Darren Bennett, San Diego Chargers (PFWA) |
Chris Gardocki, Cleveland Browns (AP-2) |
| Kick Returner |
Derrick Mason, Tennessee Titans (AP, PFWA, TSN) |
Darrick Vaughn, Atlanta Falcons (AP-2) |
| Punt Returner |
Az Hakim, St. Louis Rams (PFWA, TSN) |
|
| Special Teams |
Michael Bates, Carolina Panthers (PFWA) |
|
|
| Defense |
| Position |
First team |
Second team |
| Defensive end |
Jason Taylor, Miami Dolphins (AP, PFWA, TSN) Hugh Douglas, Philadelphia Eagles (AP, PFWA, TSN) Trevor Pryce, Denver Broncos (PFWA) |
Rob Burnett, Baltimore Ravens (AP-2) Trace Armstrong, Miami Dolphins (AP-2) |
| Defensive tackle |
Warren Sapp, Tampa Bay Buccaneers (AP, PFWA, TSN) La'Roi Glover, New Orleans Saints (AP, PFWA, TSN) |
Keith Hamilton, New York Giants (AP-2) Sam Adams, Baltimore Ravens (AP-2) |
| Middle linebacker |
Ray Lewis, Baltimore Ravens (AP, PFWA, TSN) Jeremiah Trotter, Philadelphia Eagles (AP) |
Sam Cowart, Buffalo Bills (AP-2) Stephen Boyd, Detroit Lions (AP-2t) Randall Godfrey, Tennessee Titans (AP-2t) |
| Outside linebacker |
Derrick Brooks, Tampa Bay Buccaneers (AP, PFWA, TSN) Junior Seau, San Diego Chargers (AP, PFWA, TSN) |
Jessie Armstead, New York Giants (AP-2) Mo Lewis, New York Jets (AP-2) |
| Cornerback |
Sam Madison, Miami Dolphins (AP, PFWA, TSN) Samari Rolle, Tennessee Titans (AP, PFWA, TSN) |
Charles Woodson, Oakland Raiders (AP-2) Champ Bailey, Washington Redskins (AP-2) |
| Safety |
John Lynch, Tampa Bay Buccaneers (AP, PFWA, TSN) Darren Sharper, Green Bay Packers (AP, PFWA, TSN) |
Rod Woodson, Baltimore Ravens (AP-2) Blaine Bishop, Tennessee Titans (AP-2) |
|