Persecution of Serbs in the late Ottoman era

The Principality of Serbia received autonomy from the Ottoman Empire in the early 19th century, but a Serb population remained to the south, outside of the borders of the principality. With the Serbian–Ottoman Wars (1876–1878) and the Congress of Berlin, the Serbian borders were expanded. During this time, numerous instances of violent acts were perpetrated towards local Serb populations.

Persecution of Serbs in the late Ottoman era
Map of the borders of the Principality of Serbia and the Ottoman Empire in 1878.
Location	Rumelia, Ottoman Empire (now Balkans)
Date	1878–1905
Target	Serbs
Attack type	Massacres, looting, arson, ethnic cleansing, expulsion
Victims	Western estimate: 60,000 Serbs migrated from Kosovo between 1876-1912[1]
Perpetrators	Muslim Slavs, Circassian irregulars, Albanian armed bands, Ottoman Army, Turkish gendarmes
Motive	Revenge for expulsions of Albanians from the area of Niš in 1877-1878, Anti-Serb sentiment

19th century

In the 19th century, the Serbs that lived in the Ottoman Empire experienced various forms of oppression, most of which went unreported due to a fear of reprisals. Those who filed complaints were often ignored or faced unjust Ottoman court rulings, and their hope for support rested in the consulates of the Great Powers that had been opened on Ottoman territory, particularly those of the Russians. The Russians had declared themselves to be the "protectors" of Orthodox Christians within the Ottoman empire. Partially due to the increasing pressures they placed on the Ottomans, the Sultan issued a series of reforms, some of which sought to improve the positions of Orthodox Christians within the empire. As a result, an increasing number of petitions and complaints were written by Serbs, and increasing violence by Muslim populations was exhibited towards the Serbs, who were seen as the main culprits behind the reforms.^[2]

In 1854, Vasilije Đorđević from Pristina informed Toma Kovačević about incidents in the Kosovo region, including kidnapping of women and girls and Islamization.^[3] European courts received complaints about the oppression of Christians and thus put pressure on the Porte to improve the situation. In this regard, Grand Vizier Kıbrıslı Mehmed Pasha set out to investigate matters in Rumelia ("European Turkey"). Upon hearing this, local Muslims put further pressure on the Christians in an attempt to steer them from testifying. Kıbrıslı travelled from Vidin via Pirot to Niš, where he received complaints from the Muslims that the Christians had revolted, refused to work, and had pushed them from their properties. Upon hearing this, Kıbrıslı had notable Serbs in Pirot and Niš killed, and some Serbs who escaped to Serbia informed the government about this act. The archimandrite of the Dečani Monastery, Serafim Ristić, had collected some complaints that he then gave to Kıbrıslı in Podujeva in September 1860, but no measures were taken and Kıbrıslı returned back to Istanbul. Serafim turned the complaints into a book, labelled the Cry of Old Serbia, which he published in 1864.^[4]

Of all the international consulates that had opened in the Ottoman Empire, the Russian consul in Prizren, Ivan Jastrebov (t. 1870–74; 1879; 1881–86), was the only consul who sought to improve the status of the Serbs. The Serbs in Ottoman territory had virtually no protection before the opening of Serbian consulates in 1889.^[5]

Events in the Serbian–Ottoman Wars (1876–1878)

Main article: Serbian–Ottoman Wars (1876–1878)

1876 Timok and Morava devastation

In 1876, the Ottoman army fought mainly in the Timok and Morava valleys in the territory of the Principality of Serbia, which resulted in the destruction of local areas. The Ottoman army was accompanied by Circassians and bashi-bozuks that had systematically pillaged and burnt down villages that they came across. Some of the crimes committed against the civilian population included murders, torture, rape, and slavery, and the victims included children and the elderly. Knjaževac, Zaglavak, Svrlig and their surroundings were destroyed. Osman Pasha, who had encouraged the plundering, later forbade it as he was threatened with the death penalty. The front page of The Illustrated London News of 9 September 1876 was of the plunder of Knjaževac. On 22 August 1876 Đura Horvatović wrote about the atrocities in Knjaževac, where the burnt bodies often showed signs of torture. Zaječar, which was evacuated by the Ottomans on 23 March 1877, had been completely pillaged, with houses burnt down and the church and graveyard desecrated with bodies thrown around. Aleksinac was evacuated by the Ottomans on 6 March 1877, and the houses were partly burnt, and bodies were found in wells, as in other settlements, and the local church survived destruction as it had been transformed into a mosque. In the five okrug of Aleksinac, Kruševac, Krajina, Crna Reka and Knjaževac, some 221 villages and three towns were burnt down and pillaged by the Ottoman forces. Refugees moved to the interior and a government department for the care of refugees from the frontiers, Old Serbia and Bosnia and Herzegovina was set up on 30 September 1876. By late 1876 there were 140,000 refugees in Serbia, out of which 87,948 were from the five frontier okrugs.^[6]

1877–78 Sanjak of Niš and Muslim refugees

Main article: Expulsion of the Albanians (1877–1878)

Albanians inhabited large parts of the Sanjak of Niš and formed the majority in certain areas,^[7] with modern estimates stating that the region contained more than 110,000 Albanians prior to their mass expulsion.^[1] The 1877–78 war brought Serbia into conflict with the Albanians, as they had inhabited parts of the newly-conquered territories in the Sanjak of Niš and had fought in the Ottoman army against the Serbs to defend their homes during the latter's offensive campaign in the region.^[8][9] The Serbian government considered the Albanians to be an "undesirable" and "unreliable" population that had to be replaced with a more convenient one, and they believed that Serbia should become an ethnically homogeneous country. Additionally, the territories inhabited by the Albanians was to become the base for future expansions into Kosovo and North Macedonia. As such, between 1877-78, tens of thousands of Muslims - most of whom were Albanians - were expelled by the Serbian army; the majority had left during the course of Serbian military operations in the area, and the rest were expelled after the conclusion of the war.^[10] Estimates on the exact number of Albanians and Muslims expelled from the Sanjak of Niš vary; western officials had reported a total of 60,000 Muslim refugees in Macedonia and 60-70,000 Albanian refugees in the Vilayet of Kosovo.^[1] Other modern estimates range from 70,000, of which 49,000 are estimated to be Albanians,^[11] all the way up to 160,000 Albanians.^[12] At the same time, during the Ottoman retreat from the region, Sultan Abdul Hamid II unleashed his auxiliary troops consisting of Kosovar Albanians on the remaining Serbs.^[13]

This mass expulsion would have long-term negative effects on Serbian-Albanian relations.^[14] The new Balkan Christian states pursued ethnic homogenisation policies through expelling Muslims,^[15] and this was the first gross injustice committed by Serbian forces against Albanians.^[16] It radicalized Muslim Albanian refugees who retaliated against the Serbs in Kosovo,^[16] and greatly contributed to the formation of the Albanian nationalist League of Prizren.^[15] These Albanian refugees were settled in the eastern^[15] border area of Kosovo, where Serbs had been forced out by the Ottoman authorities.^[16] Some scholars view the 1877–78 expulsions as crucial in the interethnic conflict in Kosovo,^[1][17] and from this point, both groups had experiences of mass victimization that served to justify vengeance.^[16]

Post-war events

In Toplica, the abandoned houses of Albanians were settled in 1878–79 by refugees from mainly the frontier districts that were devastated in 1876. Montenegrins were settled on the Serbian-Ottoman border on the left banks of Toplica and Kosanica to try and stop Albanian raids into Serbia.^[18] The Muslim refugees, or Muhaxhirs, that had been expelled by the Serbs in 1877-1878 were hostile to the Kosovo Serbs,^[1][15] and the Serb population was subject to retaliatory acts by Albanians, particularly after the formation of the League of Prizren following the Berlin Congress (July 1878). In the Pristina, Peja and Prizren sanjaks, several hundred were killed.^[19] The Ottoman authorities strategically placed Muslim refugees from Serbia, Montenegro, and Bosnia and Herzegovina in the northern part of the Kosovo Vilayet and actively prevented their repatriation,^[19] which was an act that had been advised by the Russian consul Ivan Yastrebov.^[1] Additionally, a wave of Muslim Slavs from Bosnia had voluntarily settled in Kosovo as they refused to live under Christian Austrian administration, and they brought with them a strong anti-Christian sentiment to the areas in which they settled.^[1]

Serbs began a steady emigration from Kosovo during this period partly as a result of retaliatory attacks from the muhaxhir refugees, but mainly due to the general stagnation and poor administration of the Vilayet of Kosovo. There was no Ottoman state policy of expelling the Serbian population, and therefore the migration of Serbs from Kosovo cannot be compared to the expulsion of Albanians from Serbia. There is a lack of precise numbers regarding the amount of Serbs who left Kosovo during this time, and most of the figures that are commonly quoted come from unreliable estimates made by biased Serbian diplomats or nationalist ethnographers of the time. Only rough estimates can be made for the total number of Serbs who migrated from Kosovo between the years of 1876-1912, with historian Noel Malcolm suggesting a figure of around 60,000.^[1] This migration, coupled with the influx of Muslim Albanian refugees, lowered the proportion of Serbs in the Kosovo Vilayet.^[1][20]

The Toplica and Vranje okrug were exposed to incursions of Albanian armed bands in 1878–80.^[21] Immediately upon the border delineation of 1878, Albanian bands began to intrude on the Serbian side, and by 1879, the incidents were quite common, consisting primarily of cattle theft, and more rarely, the burning of forests and the killing of villagers. There were 73 intrusions in 1879 in the Toplica and Vranje okrugs, leaving 39 Serbs dead and a further 25 wounded. The Kosovo Vilayet's authorities were informed about the incidents, but they did not intervene. The Vilayet's authorities arrested the perpetrators of an intrusion in May 1879, but they were freed after pressure from the League of Prizren. In 1880, the Serbian government acknowledged individual intrusions, but they were not concerned about the matter.^[22]

After the Ottoman suppression of the League of Prizren in 1881, the state of the Serbs did not improve, as the Porte still favoured Albanians over Serbs. An Ottoman military court was set up in Pristina in the springtime of 1882 which initially focused on indicting Albanian nationalist leaders, and it was then was then used to incriminate leading Serbs. In five years of activity, some 300 Serb teachers, clergy and merchants were imprisoned on fabricated charges.^[19] This was done as a warning to the Serbs in case of future wars. The Porte viewed the Albanians as trusted border protection and as a backbone of Ottoman military, with leading Albanians being part of the upper class of the Ottoman feudal system.^[23]

On 10 July 1882, archimandrite Sava Dečanac wrote a national-political programme to Prime Minister Milan Piroćanac that discussed the state of Serbs in Kosovo, in which he claimed that the Serb population was supposedly in danger of disappearing under pressure from the Albanians. In March 1883, Đorđe Kamperelić managed to escape his transfer to Asia Minor as a convict of the Pristina military court, and arrived in Serbia where the government was informed of the state of Serbs in connection with the court.^[24] In 1883, British archaeologist Arthur Evans travelled to the Kosovo Vilayet and reported that Serbs were victims of tyranny, oppression, murder, forced labour, extortion, and extraordinary taxation, "in the most abject state of misery and degradation".^[25]

In 1885–86, Albanian incursions into the border area continued, mostly for theft, but 38 Serbs were killed and many wounded.^[26] In 1886, the Porte allowed Serbia to open consulates in Ottoman territory.^[27] In 1887, the vice-consul at Skopje claimed that there was banditry and violence in the whole area between Pristina, Prizren and the Montenegrin–Ottoman border. The archimandrite Rafailo of the Dečani monastery also complained about the lawlessness. There were reports of almost daily murders, and it seems that it was worse in the Peja nahiya. In 1887, there were more incursions from both sides, but far more by Albanians. Complaints proved fruitless as the Ottoman authorities sided with the Albanians. By 1889, many from the Peja area had fled to Serbia. An Ottoman–Serbian border commission met in 1889, which lowered Albanian incursions.^[28]

In 1889, the Serbian consulate in Pristina was opened, which saw an increase in reports on acts committed against Serbs. There were risks to both the Serbs who came and told of the problems and to the consuls themselves, and the consuls were unable to offer more than comfort in words as they were limited in their work by the Ottoman authorities and the position of the young Serbian state.^[27] Many Muslim Albanians viewed these developments as the first steps towards a Serbian annexation of Kosovo, and a year later, the consul Luka Marinković was murdered.^[27][1] The new consul at Prizren reported in August 1890 that the Ottoman authorities were helpless, and he feared that by next year, the Serbs could disappear from Kosovo, especially from the Peja nahiya.^[29]

1890s

In the beginning of 1891, the Albanians of Drenica rose up in revolt against the Ottomans, which resulted in many Serbs from the Peja, Mitrovica, Pristina, Vushtrri and Gjilan nahiyas fleeing to Serbia. Stojan Novaković's impression of the situation was that the Yıldız, perhaps with the Porte's support, had a plan to destroy the Serbs in Kosovo and to strengthen the Albanian element. At the end of 1892, the situation seemed to have calmed down after the international powers suggested a commission to investigate and improve the situation in the Kosovo Vilayet. However, in 1893, small-scale rebellions under Haxhi Zeka in Peja and in Prizren, showed that much wasn't needed for the situation to blaze up again.^[30]

From 1894, the Ottoman Empire found itself in internal crisis with national liberation movements of Armenians and on Crete. Armenians were massacred. Greece, which supported the Cretans, was defeated in the Greco-Turkish War (1897). The Balkan states stayed out of that conflict and first and foremost Russia and Austria-Hungary wanted to calm things down as to not risk a greater conflict in the Balkans, thus, they worked for attaining Cretan autonomy in 1898. In case of disintegration of European Turkey, Austria-Hungary supported an independent Albania. From 1894, attacks on property and Serbs intensified in comparison to earlier years, leading to migrations from Kosovo, especially in the Peja nahiya. The Greco-Turkish War resulted in further deterioration of the situation, with the Albanians, who participated in the war, being a security for upholding Ottoman Europe and at the same contributing to anarchy.^[31] Serbs in the Ottoman Empire were maltreated and accused of being Serbian agents during and after the Greco-Turkish War. Panic ensued, and Serbs, primarily from the Ottoman border areas, fled to Serbia.^[32] As to not risk another conflict and fearing that European powers would take serious steps to ensure the protection of Christian subjects, the sultan decided to disarm the Albanians, which they refused upon meeting in late January 1899.^[33]

Early 20th century

In May 1901, Albanian bands partially set Sjenica, Novi Pazar and Pristina on fire.^[34] Albanians massacred a considerable number of Serbs in Ibarski Kolašin during the summer.^[34] Ibarski Kolašin (now known as North Kosovo) was a forested region made up of 40 villages, largely inhabited by Serbs, where Serbian teachers and priests were active, which had long irritated the Albanians and Ottoman government; Serbs were continuously maltreated in the region. Initially, the Sublime Porte did not suppress the local Albanian movements nor did it protect the Serbs. The Serbian government observed the developments in Kolašin, and did not remain idle. The Ottomans eventually intervened; the governor (vali) was dismissed, and several other anti-Serb officials and Albanian chieftains who had been especially cruel were removed from their posts.^[35] The 1901 events were instrumental in the 'Kolašin affair', a diplomatic conflict between Austria-Hungary, which supported the Albanians, and Serbia, which was supported by Russia.^[36] In the beginning of 1902, there were attacks on Serbs in the villages of Kopaonik. Albanians rose up due to the November 1902 reforms that would have given Christians improved rights. Persecution of Serbs in the Vushtrri area and failure of reforms led to the migration of Serbs to Toplica in 1903.^[37]

The pressures exerted by the Great Powers on the Ottoman Empire typically increased the suspicions and hostilities between Albanian Muslims and their Christian neighbours, and the general deterioration between the two groups during this period should be blamed primarily on external developments of this sort. As part of a long-standing tradition, Albanians had protected the Visoki Dečani monastery as late as 1898, but when the Metropolitan introduced Russian monks to the monastery, this greatly intensified the hostility of the Muslims. Even Serbian diplomats had begun to become irritated by the degree of Russian interference in Kosovo, and Serbian consular official Milan Rakić noted in 1905 that Serb villagers in the region of Deçan had absurdly begun to identify as Russians.^[1]

Wilder and misleading claims were made by Serbs during that period of time, particularly by the Serbian consul. Rakić pointed out that Serb peasants would exaggerate their sufferings in order to get financial or material help and that the number of Serb deaths was constantly overstated. In the first five months of 1905, 25 Serbs were killed in Kosovo; four of them by other Serbs and three by unknown killers. Rakić noted that many more people were killed in Serbia in the same period, and despite the aforementioned statistic, contemporary Serbian bulletins would falsely claim that Serbs were being murdered every day. Rakić also strongly criticised the Serbian consul's suggestions of stirring up feuds amongst the Albanians as well as their sponsoring of armed Serbian bands, some of which were active in Kosovo. These armed bands would sometimes fight pitched battles against local Albanians, and they significantly harmed relations between Albanians and Serbs.^[1]