| Holder | Period | Remarks |
| Created by the Catholic Monarchs |
| i | Pedro Manrique de Lara y Sandoval | 1482–1515 | |
| ii | Antonio Manrique de Lara y Castro | 1515–1535 | son. Order of the Golden Fleece |
| iii | Juan Esteban Manrique de Lara y Cardona | 1535–1558 | son. Order of the Golden Fleece |
| iv | Juan Esteban Manrique de Lara Acuña y Manuel | 1558–1600 | son. Viceroy of Valencia |
| v | Luisa Manrique de Lara y Girón | 1600–1627 | daughter. Married Bernardino de Cárdenas, 3rd Duke of Maqueda |
| vi | Jorge de Cárdenas y Manrique de Lara | 1627–1644 | son. Governor of Oran |
| vii | Jaime Manuel de Cárdenas Manrique de Lara | 1644–1652 | brother |
| viii | Francisco María de Monserrate Manrique de Cárdenas y Lara | 1652–1656 | son. No issue |
| ix | Teresa Antonia Hurtado de Mendoza y Manrique de Cárdenas | 1656–1657 | cousin. No issue |
| x | Antonio de Velasco Manrique de Mendoza Acuña y Tejada | 1657–1676 | son of her sister Nicolasa |
| xi | Francisco Miguel Manrique de Velasco | 1676–1678 | son. no issue |
| xii | Nicolasa Manrique de Mendoza Velasco Acuña y Manuel | 1678–1709 | sister, married Beltrán Vélez de Guevara |
| xiii | Ana Micaela Guevara Manrique de Velasco | 1709–1729 | daughter, married Gaspar Portocarrero y Bocanegra, Marqués de Almenara |
| xiv | Joaquín María Portocarrero Manrique de Guevara | 1729–1731 | son, died aged 3. |
| xv | Joaquín Cayetano Ponce de León y Spínola | 1731–1743 | distant cousin, VIII Duke of Arcos |
| xvi | Manuel Ponce de León y Spínola | 1743–1744 | brother |
| xvii | Francisco Cayetano Ponce de León y Spínola | 1744–1763 | brother |
| xviii | Antonio Ponce de León y Spínola | 1763–1780 | brother, Order of the Golden Fleece |
| xix | María Isidra de la Cruz de la Cerda y Manrique de Lara | 1780–1811 | distant cousin, married Diego Ventura de Guzmán, Marqués de Montealegre |
| xx | Diego Isidro de Guzmán y de la Cerda | 1811–1849 | son, Order of the Golden Fleece |
| xxi | Carlos Luis de Guzmán y la Cerda | 1850–1880 | son |
| xxii | Juan Bautista de Guzmán y Caballero | 1881–1890 | brother |
| xxiii | José Reinaldo de Guzmán y de la Cerda | 1890–1891 | brother |
| xxiv | Juan de Zavala y Guzmán | 1892–1910 | son of his sister and Juan de Zavala (1804–1879) |
| xxv | Luis de Zavala y Guzmán | 1911–1913 | brother |
| xxvi | María del Pilar de Zavala y Guzmán | 1913–1915 | sister, married Ventura García-Sancho |
| xxvii | María del Pilar García-Sancho y Zavala | 1916–1916 | daughter, married Leopoldo de Travesedo Fernández |
| xxviii | Juan Bautista de Travesedo y García-Sancho | 1917–1965 | son |
| xxix | Juan de Travesedo y Martínez de las Rivas | 1967–1996 | son |
| xxx | Juan de Travesedo y Colón de Carvajal | 2000–actual holder | son of his brother |