| Year | Recipient(s) | Work | Nominees | Ref. | 
|---|
| 1997 | Pierre Boulez (conductor) and the Ensemble Inter-Contemporain | Boulez: ...Explosante-Fixe... |  | [2] | 
| 1998 | Claudio Abbado (conductor), Berliner Philharmonic | "Hindemith: Kammermusik No. 1 With Finale 1921, Op. 24, No. 1" | 
Sian Edwards, conductor; Ensemble Modern – Adams: Chamber Symphony; Shaker Loops; Phrygian Gates for Solo PianoReinhard Goebel, conductor; Musica Antiqua Koln – Chaconne (Works of Blow, Corelli, Muffat, Etc.)Peter Phillips, conductor; The Tallis Scholars – Ockeghem: Missa De Plus En Plus, Etc./Binchois: Missa Au Travail Suis, Etc.)Philippe Herreweghe, conductor; Ensemble Vocal Europeen – Schein: The Fountains of Israel - Sacred Madrigals (O Herr, Ich Bin Dein Knecht; Ich Lasse Dich Nicht, Etc.)Philip Pickett, conductor; Musicians of the Globe – Shakespeare's Musick - Songs and Dances from Shakespeare's Plays (Works Of Byrd, Dowland, Holborne, Etc.)
 | [3] | 
| 1999 | Steve Reich (conductor), Steve Reich and Musicians | Reich: Music for 18 Musicians | 
Alexander Blachly, conductor; Pomerium – Creator of the Stars - Christmas Music for Earlier Times (Works of De Lassus, Du Fay, Byrd, Etc.)Michael Riesman, conductor; Gyuto Monks; Monks of the Drukpa Order – Glass: Kundun - Music from the Original SoundtrackAndrew Manze, conductor; Academy of Ancient Music – Handel: Concerti Grossi, Op. 6 (Nos. 1 - 12)Steve Reich and Musicians – Reich: Music for 18 MusiciansJames Rives-Jones, conductor; Voices of Change – Voces Americanas (Works of Rodriguez, Lavista, Sierra, Etc.)
 | [4] | 
| 2000 | Joseph Jennings (conductor) and Chanticleer | Colors of Love - Works of Thomas, Stucky, Tavener & Rands | 
Moscow Soloists – Brahms: Quintet in B Minor for Viola & Strings Arr. By Bashmet/Shostakovich: Thirteenth String Quartet in B Flat Minor Arr. By A. TchaikovskyJoseph Jennings, conductor; Chanticleer – Colors of Love (Works of Thomas, Stucky, Tavener, Rands, Etc.)Federico Maria Sardelli, conductor; Modo Antiquo – Corelli: Concerti Grossi, Op. 6, Nos. 7 - 12René Jacobs, conductor; Akademie für Alte Musik Berlin – Scarlatti: Il Primo OmicidioPierre Boulez, conductor; Ensemble intercontemporain – "Schoenberg: Pierrot Lunaire, Op. 21; Herzegewächse, Op. 20; Ode To Napoleon Buonaparte, Op. 41
 | [5] | 
| 2001 | Christian Gausch (producer), Wolf-Dieter Karwatky (engineer) and the Orpheus Chamber Orchestra | Shadow Dances (Stravinsky Miniatures - Tango; Suite No. 1; Octet, etc.) |  | [6] | 
| 2002 | Helmut Mühle (producer), Philipp Nedel (engineer), Gidon Kremer (producer & artist) and Kremerata Baltica | After Mozart |  | [7] | 
| 2003 | Steve Barnett (producer), Preston Smith (engineer), Joseph Jennings (conductor), Chanticleer & Handel & Haydn Society of Boston | Tavener: Lamentations and Praises |  | [8] | 
| 2004 | Jeff von der Schmidt (conductor) and Southwest Chamber Music | "Chávez: Suite for Double Quartet" |  | [9] | 
| 2005 | Jeff von der Schmidt (conductor) and Southwest Chamber Music | Chávez - Complete Chamber Music, Vol. 2 |  | [10] | 
| 2006 | Pierre Boulez (conductor), Hilary Summers (performer), and Ensemble Intercontemporain | Boulez: Le Marteau Sans Maître, Dérive 1 & 2 |  | [11] | 
| 2007 | Peter Rutenberg (conductor) and Los Angeles Chamber Singers' Cappella | Padilla: Sun of Justice |  | [12] | 
| 2008 | Yuri Bashmet (conductor) and Moscow Soloists; Michael Brammann, engineer; Philipp Nedel, producer | Stravinsky: Apollo, Concerto In D; Prokofiev: 20 Visions Fugitives | 
Stile Antico – Music for ComplineKenneth Slowik, conductor; Santa Fe Pro Musica – Mahler: Das Lied Von Der ErdeFrank Proto, conductor; Ensemble Sans Frontiere – Bridges - Eddie Daniels Plays the Music of Frank ProtoSwiss Baroque Soloists – Bach: Brandenburg Concertos
 | [13] | 
| 2009 | Charles Bruffy (conductor) and Phoenix Chorale | Spotless Rose: Hymns To The Virgin Mary |  | [14] | 
| 2010 | Paul Hillier (conductor); Robina G. Young, producer; Brad Michel, engineer/mixer and Ars Nova Copenhagen & Theatre of Voices | Lang, David: The Little Match Girl Passion |  | [15] | 
| 2011 | Jordi Savall, conductor; Hespèrion XXI & La Capella Reial de Catalunya | Dinastia Borja |  | [16] | 
| 2012 | Rinde Eckert (librettist/performer); Steven Mackey (composer/performer); David Frost, producer; Eighth Blackbird | Mackey: Lonely Motel - Music from Slide | 
Gabriela Frank (composer and performer) and Alias Chamber Ensemble – Frank: HilosRichard Savino (conductor) and El Mundo – The Kingdoms of CastillePatrick Dupré Quigley (conductor) and Seraphic Fire – A Seraphic Fire ChristmasThe Bay Brass – Sound The Bells!
 | [17] | 
| 2013 | Eighth Blackbird | Meanwhile | 
Modern Mandolin Quartet – AmericanaZOFO Duet – Mind MeldBoston Symphony Chamber Players – Profanes et SacréesLos Angeles Percussion Quartet – Rupa-Khandha
 | [18] | 
| 2014 | Brad Wells & Roomful of Teeth | Roomful of Teeth |  | [19] | 
| 2015 | Hilary Hahn & Cory Smythe | In 27 Pieces: The Hilary Hahn Encores |  | [20] | 
| 2016 | Eighth Blackbird | Filament |  | [21] | 
| 2017 | Third Coast Percussion | Steve Reich |  | [22] | 
| 2018 | Patricia Kopatchinskaja & the Saint Paul Chamber Orchestra | Death & the Maiden |  | [23] | 
| 2019 | Laurie Anderson & the Kronos Quartet | Landfall |  | [24] | 
| 2020 | Attacca Quartet (ensemble); Antonio Oliart & Caroline Shaw (producers); Antonio Oliart (engineer) | Shaw: Orange |  | [25] | 
| 2021 | Pacifica Quartet; James Ginsburg (producer); Bill Maylone (engineer/mixer) | Contemporary Voices |  | [26] | 
| 2022 | Yo-Yo Ma & Emanuel Ax | Beethoven: Cello Sonatas - Hope and Tears |  | [27] | 
| 2023 | Attacca Quartet | Shaw: Evergreen |  | [28] | 
| 2024 | Roomful of Teeth | Rough Magic |  |  | 
| 2025 | Caroline Shaw & So Percussion | Rectangles and Circumstance |  | [29] |