Barnburners and Hunkers

For a person who hunkers, see squatting position.

"Barnburner" redirects here. For a definition of that term, see the Wiktionary entry barnburner.

The Barnburners and Hunkers were the names of two opposing factions of the New York Democratic Party in the 1840s and early 1850s. The main issue dividing the two factions was that of slavery, with the Barnburners being the anti-slavery faction. While this division occurred within the context of New York politics, it reflected the national divisions in the Democratic Party in the years preceding the American Civil War.^[1][2]

Barnburners

1848 cartoon satirizing the Barnburners / Free Soil Party, referencing the Wilmot Proviso

The Barnburners were the radical faction. The term barnburner was derived from a folktale about a Dutch farmer who burned down his own barn in order to get rid of a rat infestation.^[3] In this case it was applied to men who were thought to be willing to destroy all banks and corporations, in order to root out their abuses.^[4]

The Barnburners opposed expanding the public debt, and were opposed to the power of large state-established corporations. They also generally came to oppose the extension of slavery. They also stood for local control^[vague] by the Albany Regency, as against the Polk political machine which the new administration was trying to build up in New York.^[vague]

At the 1848 presidential election, the Barnburners left the Democratic Party, refusing to support presidential nominee Lewis Cass. They joined with other anti-slavery groups, predominantly the abolitionist Liberty Party and some anti-slavery Conscience Whigs from New England and the Midwest, to form the Free Soil Party. This group nominated former President Van Buren to run again for the presidency. Their vote divided Democratic strength. Zachary Taylor, the Whig nominee, was elected to office.^{[citation needed]}

After the Compromise of 1850 temporarily neutralized the issue of slavery and undercut the party's no-compromise position, most Barnburners who had joined the Free Soil Party returned to the Democratic Party. In 1854, some Barnburners helped to form the Republican Party.

Notable Barnburners

• John Adams Dix, U.S. Senator (1845–49)
• Martin Van Buren, 8th President of the United States (1837–41)
• Walt Whitman journalist and poet. His publisher, a Hunker, fired Whitman for his Barnburner editorials as editor of the Brooklyn Daily Eagle".^[5]
• Silas Wright, Governor of New York (1846–47) and U.S. Senator (1833–44)

Hunkers

"The Modern Gilpins" - rivalry between the Hunkers and anti-slavery Democrats

The Hunkers were the relatively pro-government faction. They opposed the Barnburners, and favored state banks, internal improvements, and minimizing the slavery issue. A defining characteristic of the Hunkers was their willingness to compromise on the issue of slavery to maintain political unity and the continuation of the Democratic Party. They generally opposed the anti-slavery agitation of the Barnburners. : Hunkers typically supported state-funded internal improvements. They represented a more traditional element within the Democratic Party, tracing their roots back to Martin Van Buren's political machine.^[6]

Notable Hunkers

• Samuel Beardsley, U.S. Representative from Utica and New York Supreme Court justice
• Edwin Croswell, publisher of the Albany Argus
• Daniel S. Dickinson, U.S. Senator (1844–51)
• William L. Marcy, U.S. Secretary of State (1853–57), U.S. Secretary of War (1845–49), Governor of New York (1833–38) and U.S. Senator (1831–33)
• Horatio Seymour, Governor of New York (1853–54 and 1863–64) and Democratic nominee for President in 1868

Hards and Softs

Following the 1848 election, the Hunkers themselves split over the question of reconciliation with the Barnburners, with the Softs, led by Marcy, favoring reconciliation, and the Hards, led by Dickinson, opposing it. This split would be exacerbated following the 1852 presidential election, when disputes over patronage led to an even broader split between Hards and Softs and helped lead to the defeat of the Soft governor, Horatio Seymour, running for re-election in 1854.^[7]