ISL All-Star Team

The All-Star Teams for the now defunct British Ice Hockey Superleague were voted for by members of The British Ice Hockey Writers Association (now known as Ice Hockey Journalists UK) to honour the best players at the end of each season.

Position	Player	Team
Goaltender	Stevie Lyle	Cardiff Devils
Defence	Kip Noble	Cardiff Devils
Defence	Garth Premak	Nottingham Panthers
Forward	Paul Adey	Nottingham Panthers
Forward	Ivan Matulik	Cardiff Devils
Forward	Vezio Sacratini	Cardiff Devils

Position	Player	Team
Goaltender	Rob Dopson	Ayr Scottish Eagles
Defence	Scott Young	Ayr Scottish Eagles
Defence	Kris Miller	Manchester Storm
Forward	Ed Courtenay	Sheffield Steelers
Forward	Mark Montanari	Ayr Scottish Eagles
Forward	Craig Woodcroft	Manchester Storm

Position	Player	Team
Goaltender	Mark Bernard	Bracknell Bees
Defence	Kip Noble	Cardiff Devils
Defence	Shayne McCosh	Bracknell Bees
Forward	Tony Hand	Sheffield Steelers
Forward	Steve Thornton	Cardiff Devils
Forward	Sam Groleau	Ayr Scottish Eagles

Position	Player	Team
Goaltender	Frank Pietrangelo	Manchester Storm
Defence	Kip Noble	Cardiff Devils
Defence	Troy Neumeier	Manchester Storm
Forward	Greg Hadden	Nottingham Panthers
Forward	Ed Courtenay	Sheffield Steelers
Forward	Paul Adey	Nottingham Panthers

Position	Player	Team
Goaltender	Trevor Robins	Nottingham Panthers
Defence	Kris Miller	Manchester Storm
Defence	Rob Stewart	Bracknell Bees
Forward	Ivan Matulik	Cardiff Devils
Forward	Jeff Tomlinson	Manchester Storm
Forward	Jeff Jablonski	Manchester Storm

1996-1997

Position	Player	Team
Goaltender	Mike Bales	Belfast Giants
Defence	Johan Silfwerplatz	Ayr Scottish Eagles
Defence	Rob Stewart	Belfast Giants
Forward	Kevin Riehl	Belfast Giants
Forward	Sean Berens	Belfast Giants
Forward	Jason Ruff	Belfast Giants