Year |
Name |
Hometown |
Age |
Local Title |
Talent |
Placement at MAO Teen |
Special scholarships at MAO Teen |
Notes |
2025 |
Natalie Popp |
Fitchburg |
17 |
Miss Capital City's Teen |
Vocal |
TBA |
TBA |
|
2024 |
Ella Marie Julianne Bey |
Pewaukee |
15 |
Miss Foot of the Lake's Teen |
Dance |
TBA |
TBA |
First bi-racial teenager to win the state teen pageant |
2023 |
Trinity Faith Horstman[2] |
Onalaska |
17 |
Miss Crossing Rivers' Teen |
Tap Dance "The Devil Went Down to Georgia" |
|
|
Younger sister of Miss Wisconsin's Outstanding Teen 2019-2020, Savannah Horstman |
2022 |
Evelyn Rose Green |
Oshkosh |
17 |
Miss Oshkosh's Outstanding Teen |
Baton/Twirl |
|
|
|
2021 |
Eve Rosemary Vanden Heuvel[3] |
Freedom |
17 |
Miss Green Bay Area's Outstanding Teen |
Piano |
|
|
|
2019-20 |
Savannah Grace Horstman[4] |
Onalaska |
17 |
Miss Onalaska’s Outstanding Teen |
Vocal, "Finding Wonderland" from Wonderland: A New Alice |
|
|
Older sister of Miss Wisconsin's Teen 2023, Trinity Horstman |
2018 |
Mandi Jo Genord[5] |
Montello |
16 |
Miss Northern Lights' Outstanding Teen |
Dance, Glee cover of "I Dreamed a Dream" from Les Misérables |
|
|
3rd runner-up at Miss Wisconsin Teen USA 2018 and 2021 pageants[6]
4th runner-up at Miss Wisconsin Teen USA 2020 pageant[citation needed] |
2017 |
Grace Marie Stanke[7] |
Wausau |
15 |
Miss Harbor Cities' Outstanding Teen |
Violin, "Winter" by Vivaldi |
|
|
Later Miss Wisconsin 2022 and Miss America 2023
Top 11 at Miss Wisconsin 2021
Previously Outstanding American Miss Jr. Miss 2015[citation needed] |
2016 |
Kylene Elizabeth Spanbauer[8] |
Fond du Lac |
17 |
Miss Fond du Lac's Outstanding Teen |
Dance/Twirl, "Explosive" by Bond |
Top 11[9] |
Preliminary Talent Award[10] |
1st runner-up at Miss Wisconsin 2022
Later Miss Wisconsin 2022; assumed the title after Grace Stanke won Miss America 2023 |
2015 |
Jordenne Demiree Butler[11] |
Onalaska |
16 |
Miss River City's Outstanding Teen |
Lyrical Dance, Glee cover of "I Dreamed a Dream" from Les Misérables |
|
|
4th runner-up at Miss Wisconsin 2022
1st runner-up at Miss Wisconsin 2021[12] |
2014 |
Elise MacKenzie O'Connell[13] |
Trevor |
17 |
Miss Fox River Valley's Outstanding Teen |
Musical Theatre Vocal, "On My Way" from Violet |
|
Non-finalist Talent Award[14] |
Previously National American Miss Wisconsin Pre-Teen 2008[citation needed]
2nd runner-up at Miss Wisconsin 2018 and 2019 pageants[15][16] Later, Miss Chicago 2023 |
2013 |
JamieNicole Morelan[17] |
Racine |
16 |
Miss Racine's Outstanding Teen |
Vocal, "Don't Rain on My Parade" |
Top 10[18][19] |
Top 5 Interview Award |
Sister of Miss Wisconsin's Outstanding Teen 2009 and Miss America's Outstanding Teen 2010, Jeanette Morelan[19]
Previously National American Miss Wisconsin Princess 2003[citation needed]
Previously National American Miss Wisconsin Pre-Teen 2010[citation needed]
Later Distinguished Young Woman of Wisconsin 2015[20] |
2012 |
Madeline Carol Morgan[21] |
Oregon |
16 |
Miss West Allis' Outstanding Teen |
Piano, “She Sings” |
|
|
Previously National American Miss Wisconsin Jr Teen 2011[citation needed] |
2011 |
Ann (Annie) Marie Jorgensen[22] |
Milwaukee |
16 |
Miss Milwaukee's Outstanding Teen |
Dance, "Cosmic Dance" by Florence and the Machine |
|
|
Later Miss Georgia 2018[23] |
2010 |
Teaka Marie Griesbach[24] |
Combined Locks |
15 |
Miss Milwaukee's Outstanding Teen |
Dance |
|
|
Previously National American Miss Wisconsin Jr Teen 2009[citation needed]
1st runner-up at Miss Wisconsin Teen USA 2013 pageant[citation needed]
2nd runner-up at Miss Wisconsin Teen USA 2014 pageant[25]
3rd runner-up at Miss Wisconsin USA 2016 pageant[26]
2nd runner-up at Miss Wisconsin USA 2017 and 2018 pageants[27]
1st runner-up at Miss Wisconsin USA 2019 pageant[28] |
2009 |
Kiersten Anne Gonzales[22] |
Pleasant Prairie |
17 |
Miss Milwaukee's Outstanding Teen |
Vocal, "The Art Is Calling for Me" |
N/A |
Assumed title when Morelan was named Miss America's Outstanding Teen 2010 |
Jeanette Helen Morelan[19][29] |
Racine |
15 |
Miss Southern Wisconsin's Outstanding Teen |
Vocal, “Think of Me” from The Phantom of The Opera |
Winner[29][30] |
|
Sister of Miss Wisconsin's Outstanding Teen 2013, JamieNicole Morelan[19]
Previously National American Miss Wisconsin Jr Pre-Teen 2004[citation needed]
Previously National American Miss Wisconsin Pre-Teen 2006[citation needed]
Later Distinguished Young Woman of Wisconsin 2012[31]
4th runner-up at Miss Tennessee 2016 pageant[32] |
2008 |
Jennifer Frances Dombrowski[33]
[34] |
Milwaukee |
17 |
Miss Milwaukee's Outstanding Teen |
Irish Step Dance |
|
|
|
2007 |
Bishara Abridasheed Dorre[35] |
Milwaukee |
17 |
Miss Milwaukee's Outstanding Teen |
Dance |
Top 10[22] |
Preliminary Lifestyle and Fitness Award |
Previously Miss Wisconsin Teen USA 2006[36] Previously National American Miss Wisconsin Jr Teen 2004[citation needed]
Previously National American Miss Wisconsin Teen 2008[citation needed]
Previously National American Miss Wisconsin 2009[citation needed]
Previously National American Miss 2010[citation needed]
Later Miss Wisconsin USA 2014[37] Top 10 at Miss USA 2014 pageant[37] |
2006 |
Alexandra (Allie) Rick[22] |
Greendale |
15 |
At-Large |
Dance |
Top 10[38] |
|
|
2005 |
Tonya Marie Popowski[39] |
St. Francis |
17 |
Miss West Allis' Outstanding Teen |
Dance/Twirl |
|
|
|