No. |
Result |
Record |
Opponent |
Type |
Round |
Date |
Location |
Notes |
60 |
Win |
54–2–3 (1) |
Bob Ferguson |
KO |
6 (?) |
Oct 11, 1891 |
Picnic Grove, Richardson, Illinois, US |
Retained Northwestern heavyweight title |
59 |
Win |
53–2–3 (1) |
Joe Sheehy |
DQ |
2 (15) |
Dec 19, 1890 |
Jackson Street Rink, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US |
Retained Northwestern heavyweight title; Sheehy was DQ'd for throwing Killen to ground four times, stomping on him, and biting him in the chest, the leg, and the stomach. |
58 |
Loss |
52–2–3 (1) |
Joe McAuliffe |
KO |
7 (?) |
Sep 11, 1889 |
Golden State A.C., San Francisco, California, US |
Killen reportedly entered the fight drunk and missed so wildly on his punches, that he fell and dislocated his right shoulder in the second round |
57 |
Win |
52–1–3 (1) |
Jack Welch |
KO |
3 (?) |
Aug 14, 1889 |
Astoria, Oregon, US |
|
56 |
Win |
51–1–3 (1) |
Jack Fraser |
KO |
3 (?) |
Jul 22, 1889 |
Spokane Falls, Washington, US |
|
55 |
Win |
50–1–3 (1) |
Jack Smith |
KO |
2 (?) |
Jul 16, 1889 |
Tacoma, Washington, US |
Exact date unknown |
54 |
Win |
49–1–3 (1) |
Corporal Toomey |
KO |
1 (?) |
Jul 11, 1889 |
Miles City, Montana, US |
|
53 |
Win |
48–1–3 (1) |
Patsy Cardiff |
KO |
4 (15) |
Jun 26, 1888 |
Washington Roller Rink, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |
Won Northwestern heavyweight title |
52 |
Win |
47–1–3 (1) |
Jack Cooper |
KO |
1 (?) |
Jan 1, 1888 |
Theatre Comique, Minneapolis |
Exact date unknown |
51 |
Win |
46–1–3 (1) |
Lem McGregor |
PTS |
6 |
Dec 16, 1887 |
Cominique Theater, Minneapolis |
|
50 |
Win |
45–1–3 (1) |
Frank Cook |
KO |
2 (?) |
Nov 25, 1887 |
Duluth, Minnesota, US |
|
49 |
Win |
44–1–3 (1) |
O.H. Smith |
KO |
2 (?) |
Nov 17, 1887 |
Rochester, New York, US |
|
48 |
Win |
43–1–3 (1) |
Frank Lewis |
KO |
1 (?) |
Oct 12, 1887 |
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |
|
47 |
Win |
42–1–3 (1) |
Henry Dows |
KO |
1 (?) |
Sep 7, 1887 |
Covington, Kentucky, US |
|
46 |
Win |
41–1–3 (1) |
James Smith |
KO |
1 (?) |
Sep 5, 1887 |
Covington |
|
45 |
Draw |
40–1–3 (1) |
Patsy Cardiff |
PTS |
10 |
Aug 5, 1887 |
Duluth Theatre, Duluth |
For Northwest heavyweight title |
44 |
Win |
40–1–2 (1) |
O.H. Smith |
KO |
1 (?) |
May 2, 1887 |
Duluth Theatre, Duluth |
|
43 |
Win |
39–1–2 (1) |
Jack Cook |
KO |
1 (?) |
Apr 1, 1887 |
Duluth |
|
42 |
Win |
38–1–2 (1) |
Duncan McDonald |
KO |
1 (10), 2:46 |
Mar 4, 1887 |
Washington Roller Rink, Minneapolis |
|
41 |
Win |
37–1–2 (1) |
Paddy McDonald |
KO |
7 (10) |
Jan 17, 1887 |
Duluth |
|
40 |
Win |
36–1–2 (1) |
O.H. Smith |
KO |
2 (5) |
Jan 4, 1887 |
Jackson Theater, Duluth |
|
39 |
Win |
35–1–2 (1) |
Ed McKeown |
KO |
5 (?) |
Dec 28, 1886 |
Location unknown |
|
38 |
Draw |
34–1–2 (1) |
Bill Bradburn |
PTS |
5 |
Dec 23, 1886 |
Exposition Rink, Saint Paul, Minnesota |
Bradburn refused to fight, because the money was insufficient, and had only agreed to spar five rounds with large gloves. |
37 |
Win |
34–1–1 (1) |
John Cusick |
PTS |
6 |
Nov 12, 1886 |
Theatre Comique, Minneapolis |
|
36 |
Win |
33–1–1 (1) |
Tug Wilson |
KO |
4 (?) |
Oct 24, 1886 |
Duluth |
Exact date unknown |
35 |
Win |
32–1–1 (1) |
Luke Dempsey |
KO |
1 (4) |
Oct 16, 1886 |
Exposition Rink, Saint Paul |
|
34 |
Win |
31–1–1 (1) |
Mike Haley |
KO |
4 (?) |
Sep 15, 1886 |
Omaha, Nebraska, US |
|
33 |
Win |
30–1–1 (1) |
Dan Stalker |
KO |
2 (?) |
Aug 15, 1886 |
Eau Claire, Wisconsin, US |
|
32 |
Draw |
29–1–1 (1) |
Paddy McDonald |
PTS |
4 |
Aug 7, 1886 |
Duluth |
Prearranged draw in case of a decision |
31 |
Win |
29–1 (1) |
Jim Brady |
KO |
1 (?) |
Aug 2, 1886 |
Milwaukee, Wisconsin, US |
|
30 |
Win |
28–1 (1) |
Tom Donnelly |
KO |
2 (?) |
Jul 2, 1886 |
Saint Paul |
|
29 |
Win |
27–1 (1) |
Captain Jim Daly |
KO |
3 (6) |
Jul 2, 1886 |
Theatre Comique, Minneapolis |
|
28 |
Win |
26–1 (1) |
Dan Stalker |
KO |
2 (5) |
Jun 19, 1886 |
Olympic Theater, Saint Paul |
|
27 |
Win |
25–1 (1) |
John Morris |
KO |
2 (?) |
Jun 7, 1886 |
Minneapolis |
|
26 |
Win |
24–1 (1) |
Captain James Dalton |
KO |
3 (?) |
Jun 1, 1886 |
Minneapolis |
|
25 |
Win |
23–1 (1) |
Patsy Mellen |
KO |
2 (?) |
May 2, 1886 |
Theatre Comique, Minneapolis |
|
24 |
Loss |
22–1 (1) |
Mervine Thompson |
DQ |
4 (?) |
Apr 20, 1886 |
Cleveland Crib Club, Cleveland, Ohio, US |
After scoring four knockdowns, Killen was inexplicably DQ'd when the fans rushed into the ring. |
23 |
Win |
22–0 (1) |
Bill Jordan |
KO |
3 (?) |
Apr 8, 1886 |
Vine Street Opera House, Cincinnati, Ohio, US |
|
22 |
Win |
21–0 (1) |
Mike Smith |
KO |
1 (?) |
Apr 7, 1886 |
Vine Street Opera House, Cincinnati |
|
21 |
Win |
20–0 (1) |
John Hughes |
KO |
3 (?) |
Apr 6, 1886 |
Cincinnati |
|
20 |
Win |
19–0 (1) |
Mike Haley |
KO |
2 (?) |
Apr 5, 1886 |
People's Theater, Omaha |
|
19 |
Win |
18–0 (1) |
Dan Stalker |
KO |
1 (?), 0:21 |
Apr 2, 1886 |
Criterion Rink, Eau Claire |
|
18 |
Win |
17–0 (1) |
Jim Brady |
KO |
1 (5), 2:40 |
Mar 28, 1886 |
South Side Palace Rink, Milwaukee |
|
17 |
Win |
16–0 (1) |
John Hughes |
TKO |
1 (4) |
Mar 18, 1886 |
Vine Street Opera House, Cincinnati |
|
16 |
NC |
15–0 (1) |
Pat McHugh |
NC |
6 (?) |
Mar 6, 1886 |
Park Theatre, Chicago, Illinois, US |
Fight stopped for dirty tactics by both fighters |
15 |
Win |
15–0 |
George Gray |
KO |
2 (?) |
Feb 26, 1886 |
Louisville, Kentucky, US |
|
14 |
Win |
14–0 |
Martin McComiskey |
KO |
4 (?) |
Feb 15, 1886 |
Covington |
|
13 |
Win |
13–0 |
Dick Burke |
KO |
1 (?) |
Feb 5, 1886 |
Park Theatre, Chicago |
|
12 |
Win |
12–0 |
Pat McHugh |
KO |
4 (?) |
Jan 6, 1886 |
Chicago |
|
11 |
Win |
11–0 |
George Gray |
KO |
3 (5) |
Dec 21, 1885 |
Liederkrauz Hall, Louisville |
|
10 |
Win |
10–0 |
Joe Lannon |
KO |
9 |
Nov 8, 1885 |
Silk's Grove, Saint Paul |
A finish fight |
9 |
Win |
9–0 |
Jack Morris |
KO |
2 (?) |
Sep 3, 1885 |
Park Theatre, Chicago |
|
8 |
Win |
8–0 |
John Lynch |
KO |
3 (?) |
Aug 2, 1885 |
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |
|
7 |
Win |
7–0 |
Dan Ring |
KO |
1 (?) |
Aug 1, 1885 |
Binghamton, New York, US |
Exact date uncertain |
6 |
Win |
6–0 |
Denny Kelliher |
KO |
4 (?) |
May 3, 1885 |
Philadelphia |
|
5 |
Win |
5–0 |
Mike Devine |
KO |
1 (?) |
Nov 2, 1884 |
Comique Theatre, Philadelphia |
|
4 |
Win |
4–0 |
Tom Boylan |
KO |
5 (?) |
Apr 2, 1884 |
Location unknown |
|
3 |
Win |
3–0 |
Lew Creamer |
KO |
2 (?) |
Nov 1, 1883 |
Location unknown |
Exact date uncertain |
2 |
Win |
2–0 |
Hial Stoddard |
KO |
1 (?) |
Sep 8, 1883 |
Club Theater, Philadelphia |
|
1 |
Win |
1–0 |
John Howard |
KO |
2 (?) |
Jul 6, 1883 |
Philadelphia |
|