| Award |
Recipient |
Result |
| Ultimate Scream |
Batman Begins |
Won |
| The Devil's Rejects |
Nominated |
| The Hills Have Eyes |
Nominated |
| Lost |
Nominated |
| Superman Returns |
Nominated |
| Best Horror Movie |
The Devil's Rejects |
Won |
| Land of the Dead |
Nominated |
| High Tension |
Nominated |
| The Hills Have Eyes |
Nominated |
| Hostel |
Nominated |
| Best Fantasy Movie |
Batman Begins |
Nominated |
| Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire |
Nominated |
| King Kong |
Nominated |
| Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest |
Won |
| Superman Returns |
Nominated |
| Corpse Bride |
Nominated |
| Best Science Fiction Movie |
Aeon Flux |
Nominated |
| A Scanner Darkly |
Nominated |
| Serenity |
Nominated |
| V for Vendetta |
Won |
| War of the Worlds |
Nominated |
| Best TV Show |
Battlestar Galactica |
Won |
| Doctor Who |
Nominated |
| Heroes |
Nominated |
| Lost |
Nominated |
| Masters of Horror |
Nominated |
| Smallville |
Nominated |
| Best Sequel |
Batman Begins |
Nominated |
| George A. Romero's Land of the Dead |
Nominated |
| Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest |
Won |
| Saw II |
Nominated |
| Superman Returns |
Nominated |
| Best Remake |
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory |
Nominated |
| The Hills Have Eyes |
Nominated |
| King Kong |
Won |
| The Omen |
Nominated |
| War of the Worlds |
Nominated |
| Best Superhero |
Christian Bale as Batman, Batman Begins |
Nominated |
| Chris Evans as the Human Torch, Fantastic Four |
Nominated |
| Hugh Jackman as Wolverine, X-Men: The Last Stand |
Nominated |
| Famke Janssen as Phoenix, X-Men: The Last Stand |
Nominated |
| Brandon Routh as Superman, Superman Returns |
Won |
| Sexiest Superhero |
Jessica Alba as The Invisible Woman, Fantastic Four |
Won |
| Famke Janssen as Phoenix, X-Men: The Last Stand |
Nominated[2] |
| Halle Berry as Storm, X-Men: The Last Stand |
Nominated |
| Uma Thurman as G Girl, My Super Ex-Girlfriend |
Nominated[10] |
| Best Comic-to-Screen Adaptation |
Batman Begins |
Nominated |
| A History of Violence |
Nominated |
| Superman Returns |
Nominated |
| V for Vendetta |
Nominated |
| X-Men: The Last Stand |
Won |
| Most Memorable Mutilation |
Eaten alive, George A. Romero's Land of the Dead |
Nominated |
| The eye removal, Hostel |
Won |
| Stabbed in a pit of syringes, Saw II |
Nominated |
| Suicide by shotgun, The Hills Have Eyes |
Nominated |
| Vaporized by aliens, War of the Worlds |
Nominated |
| Most Heroic Performance |
Christian Bale as Batman, Batman Begins |
Nominated |
| Johnny Depp as Captain Jack Sparrow, Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest |
Won |
| Viggo Mortensen as Tom Stall, A History of Violence |
Nominated |
| Edward James Olmos as Commander William Adama, Battlestar Galactica |
Nominated |
| Hugo Weaving as V, V for Vendetta |
Nominated[11] |
| Scream Queen |
Asia Argento as Slack, Land of the Dead |
Nominated |
| Kate Beckinsale as Selene, Underworld: Evolution |
Won |
| Evangeline Lilly, as Kate Austen, Lost |
Nominated |
| Natalie Portman as Evey Hammond, V for Vendetta |
Nominated |
| Naomi Watts as Ann Darrow, King Kong |
Nominated |
| Most Vile Villain |
Tobin Bell as Jigsaw, Saw II |
Nominated |
| Leslie Easterbrook (Mother Firefly), Sid Haig (Captain Spaulding), Bill Moseley (Otis B. Driftwood), and Sheri Moon Zombie (Baby) as the Firefly Clan, The Devil's Rejects |
Won |
| Sir Ian McKellen as Magneto, X-Men: The Last Stand |
Nominated |
| Cillian Murphy as Scarecrow, Batman Begins |
Nominated |
| Philippe Nahon as The Killer, High Tension |
Nominated |
| Breakout Performance |
Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje as Mr. Eko, Lost |
Nominated |
| Jennifer Carpenter as Emily Rose, The Exorcism of Emily Rose |
Won |
| Tricia Helfer as Number Six, Battlestar Galactica |
Nominated |
| Brandon Routh as Superman, Superman Returns |
Nominated |
| Katee Sackhoff as Starbuck, Battlestar Galactica |
Nominated |
| Best Ensemble |
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest |
Won[12] |
| Fantasy Fox |
Evangeline Lilly as Kate Austen, Lost |
Won[12] |
| "Holy Sh%t" |
Alien pods emerge from the Earth, War of the Worlds |
Nominated |
| The diner shootout, A History of Violence |
Nominated |
| The eye removal, Hostel |
Won |
| The Space Shuttle/Boeing 777 rescue, Superman Returns |
Nominated |
| The train sequence, Batman Begins |
Nominated |
| Best Director |
Alexandre Aja, The Hills Have Eyes |
Won |
| David Cronenberg, A History of Violence |
Nominated |
| Christopher Nolan, Batman Begins |
Nominated |
| Bryan Singer, Superman Returns |
Nominated |
| Rob Zombie, The Devil's Rejects |
Nominated |
| Best Screamplay |
Batman Begins, written by David S. Goyer and Christopher Nolan |
Won |
| The Devil's Rejects, written by Rob Zombie |
Nominated |
| Hostel, written by Eli Roth |
Nominated |
| Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest, written by Ted Elliott and Terry Rossio |
Nominated |
| V for Vendetta, the Wachowskis |
Nominated |
| Best Rack on the Rack |
Emma Frost |
Nominated |
| Lady Death |
Nominated |
| Power Girl |
Nominated |
| Vampirella |
Won |
| Wonder Woman |
Nominated |
| Best Foreign Movie |
2046 |
Nominated |
| High Tension |
Won |
| Night Watch |
Nominated |
| Sympathy for Lady Vengeance |
Nominated |
| Sympathy for Mr. Vengeance |
Nominated |
| Three... Extremes |
Nominated |
| Best Flesh Scene |
Jessica Alba, Fantastic Four |
Nominated |
| Maria Bello & Viggo Mortensen, A History of Violence |
Nominated |
| Famke Janssen & Hugh Jackman, X-Men: The Last Stand |
Won |
| Milla Jovovich, Ultraviolet |
Nominated |
| Jay Hernandez, Jana Kaderabkova, Barbara Nedeljakova, and Derek Richardson, Hostel |
Nominated |
| Rebecca Romijn, X-Men: The Last Stand |
Nominated |
| Best Comic Book |
All-Star Superman (DC Comics) |
Nominated |
| Civil War (Marvel Comics) |
Nominated |
| Ex Machina (Wildstorm Productions) |
Nominated |
| Marvel Zombies (Marvel Comics) |
Won |
| The Walking Dead (Image Comics) |
Nominated |
| Best Screen-To-Comic Adaptation |
Army of Darkness |
Won |
| The Fountain |
Nominated |
| Masters of Horror |
Nominated |
| Saw |
Nominated |
| Shaun of the Dead |
Nominated |
| Texas Chainsaw Massacre |
Nominated |
| Best Comic Book Writer |
Robert Kirkman, The Walking Dead / Marvel Zombies |
Nominated |
| Mark Millar, Civil War / The Ultimates |
Nominated |
| Frank Miller, Batman & Robin |
Won |
| Paul Pope, Batman: Year 100 |
Nominated |
| Brian K. Vaughan, Ex Machina / Runaways / Y: The Last Man |
Nominated |
| Best Comic Book Artist |
Charlie Adlard, The Walking Dead |
Nominated |
| Doug Braithwaite and Alex Ross, Justice |
Nominated |
| Sean Phillips, Marvel Zombies |
Won |
| Paul Pope, Batman: Year 100 |
Nominated |
| Frank Quitely, All-Star Superman |
Nominated |
| Best F/X |
King Kong |
Nominated |
| Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest |
Won |
| Superman Returns |
Nominated |
| War of the Worlds |
Nominated |
| X-Men: The Last Stand |
Nominated |
| Best Internet Parody |
How Superman Should Have Ended, www.howitshouldhaveended.com |
Won |
| Most Shocking Comic Book Twist |
Batwoman is a lesbian |
Nominated |
| Jason Todd returns as the Red Hood (Batman #635) |
Nominated |
| Galactus is eaten by zombies (Marvel Zombies #5) |
Nominated |
| Nitro blows up a schoolyard full of kids (Civil War #1) |
Nominated |
| Peter Parker outs himself as Spider-Man (Civil War #2) |
Won |
| Most Anticipated Movie † |
Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End[12] |
Won |