| Year | Program | Site | Most Valuable Player |
| 1979 | Mercer | Centenary Park • Shreveport, Louisiana, | – |
| 1980 | Georgia Southern | Luther Williams Field • Macon, Georgia, | – |
| 1981 | Mercer | Hunter Field • Abilene, Texas, | – |
| 1982 | Hardin–Simmons | Luther Williams Field • Macon, Georgia | – |
| 1983 | Mercer | Centenary Park, SPAR Stadium • Shreveport, Louisiana | – |
| 1984 | Nicholls State | Centenary Park • Shreveport, Louisiana | – |
| 1985 | Georgia Southern | J. I. Clements Stadium • Statesboro, Georgia, | Craig Cooper, Ga. Southern |
| 1986 | Georgia Southern | Hunter Field • Abilene, Texas | Mike Shepherd, Ga. Southern |
| 1987 | Georgia Southern | J. I. Clements Stadium • Statesboro, Georgia | Brett Hendley, Ga. Southern |
| 1988 | Stetson | Centenary Park • Shreveport, Louisiana | Mike Sempeles, Stetson |
| 1989 | Stetson | Conrad Park • DeLand, Florida, | Mike Pinckes, Stetson |
| 1990 | Stetson | Centenary Park • Shreveport, Louisiana | Todd Greene, Ga. Southern |
| 1991 | FIU | Conrad Park • DeLand, Florida | Kevin Lucero, FIU |
| 1992 | Southeastern Louisiana | Southeastern Louisiana Diamond • Hammond, Louisiana, | Kirk Bullinger, SLU |
| 1993 | UCF | Conrad Park • DeLand, Florida | Tony Marrillia, UCF |
| 1994 | Southeastern Louisiana | Claude Smith Field • Macon, Georgia | Dan Newman, SLU |
| 1995 | UCF | Homestead Athletic Complex • Homestead, Florida, | Todd Tocco, UCF |
| 1996 | UCF | Conrad Park • DeLand, Florida | Nick Presto, FAU |
| 1997 | UCF | Gregg Pacitti, UCF |
| 1998 | FIU | Osceola County Stadium • Kissimmee, Florida, | Edwin Franco, FIU |
| 1999 | Jacksonville | Jeff Nebel, Mercer |
| 2000 | Stetson | Alexander Brest Field • Jacksonville, Florida, | Jeff Christy, Stetson |
| 2001 | UCF | Jeremy Kurella, UCF |
| 2002 | UCF | Melching Field at Conrad Park • DeLand, Florida | Mike Myers, UCF |
| 2003 | Jacksonville | Gordie Gronkowski, Jacksonville |
| 2004 | Florida Atlantic | Rusty Brown, FAU |
| 2005 | Stetson | Shane Jordan, Stetson |
| 2006 | Stetson | Brandon Paritz, Stetson |
| 2007 | Jacksonville | Pete Clifford, Jacksonville |
| 2008 | Lipscomb | Caleb Joseph, Lipscomb |
| 2009 | Jacksonville | Alex Martinez, Jacksonville |
| 2010 | Mercer | Ken Dugan Field at Stephen Lee Marsh Stadium • Nashville, Tennessee, | Jacob Tanis, Mercer |
| 2011 | Belmont | Derek Hamblen, Belmont |
| 2012 | Belmont | Melching Field at Conrad Park • DeLand, Florida | Judah Akers, Belmont |
| 2013 | East Tennessee State | Kerry Doane, ETSU |
| 2014 | Kennesaw State | Swanson Stadium • Fort Myers, Florida, | Brennan Morgan, KSU |
| 2015 | Lipscomb | Swanson Stadium • Fort Myers, Florida | Jonathan Allison, Lipscomb |
| 2016 | Stetson | Ken Dugan Field at Stephen Lee Marsh Stadium • Nashville, Tennessee | Cory Reid, Stetson |
| 2017 | Florida Gulf Coast | Melching Field at Conrad Park • DeLand, Florida | Marc Coffers, FGCU |
| 2018 | Stetson | Harmon Stadium • Jacksonville, Florida, | Eric Foggo, Stetson |
| 2019 | Liberty | Melching Field at Conrad Park • DeLand, Florida | Jonathan Embry, Liberty |
| 2020 | Canceled due to the COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2021 | Jacksonville | Division Round: Campus sites
Semifinals and final: Harmon Stadium • Jacksonville, FL | Tyler Santana, Jacksonville |
| 2022 | Kennesaw State | Swanson Stadium • Fort Myers, FL | Josh Hatcher, Kennesaw State |
| 2023 | Lipscomb | Melching Field at Conrad Park • DeLand, FL | Alex Vergara, Lipscomb |
| 2024 | Stetson | Lorenzo Meola, Stetson |
| 2025† | Stetson
Florida Gulf Coast | |