| Name | 
Tenure | 
President appointed by | 
Notes | 
Citation(s) | 
 | Johnathan N. Baily | March 31, 1831–Nov. 2, 1832 | Andrew Jackson (Democrat) | First postmaster | [2][3] | 
 | John S.C. Hogan | Nov. 2, 1832–1837 |  | [2] | 
 | Sidney Abell | Mar. 3, 1837–1841 | Martin Van Buren (Democrat) |  | [3][4] | 
 | William Stuart | Jul. 10 1841–1845 | John Tyler (Whig) |  | [3][4] | 
 | Hart L. Stuart | Apr. 25, 1845–1849 | James K. Polk (Democrat) |  | [3][4] | 
 | Richard L. Wilson | Apr. 23, 1849–1850 | Zachary Taylor (Whig) |  | [3][4] | 
 | George W. Dole | Sep. 25, 1850–1853 | Millard Fillmore (Whig) |  | [3][4] | 
 | Isaac Cook | Mar. 22, 1853–1857 | Franklin Pierce (Democrat) |  | [3][4] | 
 | William Price | Mar. 18, 1857–1858 | James Buchanan (Democratic) |  | [3][4] | 
 | Isaac Cook | Mar. 9, 1858–1861 |  | [3][4] | 
  | John Locke Scripps | March 28, 1861–Mar. 9, 1865 | Abraham Lincoln (Republican) |  | [3][4] | 
 | Samuel Hoard | Mar. 9, 1865–1866 | Abraham Lincoln (Republican) |  | [3][4] | 
 | Robert A. Gilmore | Nov. 16, 1866–1867 | Andrew Johnson (Democrat) |  | [3][4] | 
  | Francis Trowbridge Sherman | Aug. 27, 1867–1869 |  | [3][4] | 
 | Francis A. Eastman | Apr. 5, 1869–1873 | Ulysses S. Grant (Republican) |  | [3][4] | 
  | John McArthur | Dec. 20, 1873–1877 |  | [3][4] | 
  | Francis Wayland Palmer | Feb. 26, 1877–1885 | Rutherford B. Hayes (Republican) |  | [3][4] | 
  | S. Corning Judd | May 5, 1885–1888 | Grover Cleveland (Democrat) |  | [3][4] | 
  | Walter C. Newberry | Nov. 19, 1888–1889 |  | [3][4] | 
  | James A. Sexton | Apr. 16, 1889–1893 | Benjamin Harrison (Republican) |  | [3][4] | 
  | Washington Hesing | Nov. 25, 1893–1897 | Grover Cleveland (Democrat) |  | [3][4] | 
  | Charles Ulysses Gordon | Mar. 19, 1897–1901 | William McKinley (Republican) |  | [3][4] | 
  | Frederick E. Coyne | Mar. 19, 1901–1905 |  |  | [3][4] | 
  | Fred A. Busse | Dec. 16, 1905–1907 | Theodore Roosevelt (Republican) |  | [3][4] | 
  | Daniel A. Campbell | Apr. 6, 1907–1917 |  | [3][4] | 
 | William B. Carlile | Mar. 16, 1917–1921 | Woodrow Wilson (Democrat) |  | [3][4] | 
  | Arthur C. Lueder | Aug. 24, 1921–1923 | Warren G. Harding (Republican) | Resigned in 1923 to unsuccessfully run for mayor of Chicago in that year's election as a Republican. | [3][4] | 
 | Grant B. Miller | 1923 | Warren G. Harding |  |  (Republican)  [5] | 
  | Arthur C. Lueder | 1923–1933 | Warren G. Harding (Republican) | Reappointed postmaster after losing mayoral election. | [3][4] | 
 | Ernest J. Kruetgen | Aug. 31, 1933–1948 (acting postmaster Aug. 31, 1933–Jan. 31, 1934) | Franklin D. Roosevelt (Democrat) |  | [3][4] | 
 | John Haderlein | Aug. 31, 1949–1952 (acting postmaster Aug. 31, 1948–Sep. 23, 1949) | Harry S. Truman (Democrat) |  | [3][4] | 
 | Vincent F. Werner (acting postmaster) | Aug. 31, 1952–Jul. 6, 1953 |  | [3][4] | 
 | Carl A. Shroeder | Jul. 6, 1953–1961 (acting postmaster Jul. 6, 1953–Aug. 12, 1954) | Dwight D. Eisenhower (Republican) |  | [3][4] | 
 | Ralph G. Donegan (unofficial acting postmaster) | Sep. 15, 1961–Nov. 2, 1961 | — |  | [3][4][6] | 
 | Harry H. Semrow | November 2, 1861–Mar. 1966 (acting postmaster Nov 2, 1961–Oct. 5, 1962) | John F. Kennedy (Democrat) |  | [3][4][7][8] | 
 | William Boschelli (acting postmaster) | Mar. 18, 1966–Sep. 1966 | Lyndon B. Johnson (Democrat) |  | [3][4] | 
 | Henry W. McGee Jr. | Nov. 5, 1966 and 1966–Mar. 1972 (acting postmaster Sep 23, 1966–Nov. 5, 1966) | First African American to hold the position | [3][1][4] |