Top Qs
Timeline
Chat
Perspective

Destructive dilemma

Rule of inference of propositional logic From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Remove ads

Destructive dilemma[1][2] is the name of a valid rule of inference of propositional logic. It is the inference that, if P implies Q and R implies S and either Q is false or S is false, then either P or R must be false. In sum, if two conditionals are true, but one of their consequents is false, then one of their antecedents has to be false. Destructive dilemma is the disjunctive version of modus tollens. The disjunctive version of modus ponens is the constructive dilemma. The destructive dilemma rule can be stated:

Quick Facts Type, Field ...
Remove ads

where the rule is that wherever instances of "", "", and "" appear on lines of a proof, "" can be placed on a subsequent line.

Remove ads

Formal notation

Summarize
Perspective

The destructive dilemma rule may be written in sequent notation:

where is a metalogical symbol meaning that is a syntactic consequence of , , and in some logical system;

and expressed as a truth-functional tautology or theorem of propositional logic:

where , , and are propositions expressed in some formal system.

Remove ads

Natural language example

If it rains, we will stay inside.
If it is sunny, we will go for a walk.
Either we will not stay inside, or we will not go for a walk, or both.
Therefore, either it will not rain, or it will not be sunny, or both.

Proof

More information , ...

Example proof

Summarize
Perspective

The validity of this argument structure can be shown by using both conditional proof (CP) and reductio ad absurdum (RAA) in the following way:

1.(CP assumption)
2.(1: simplification)
3.(2: simplification)
4.(2: simplification)
5.(1: simplification)
6.(RAA assumption)
7.(6: De Morgan's Law)
8.(7: simplification)
9.(7: simplification)
10.(8: double negation)
11.(9: double negation)
12.(3,10: modus ponens)
13.(4,11: modus ponens)
14.(12: double negation)
15.(5, 14: disjunctive syllogism)
16.(13,15: conjunction)
17.(6-16: RAA)
18.(1-17: CP)
Remove ads

References

Loading content...

Bibliography

Loading content...
Loading related searches...

Wikiwand - on

Seamless Wikipedia browsing. On steroids.

Remove ads