| No. | Result | Record | Opponent | Type | Round | Date | Location | Notes | 
| 83 | Win | 54–12–15 (2) | Mr. Thomas | TKO | 4 (?) | Dec 15, 1900 | Clark and Langes Clubroom, Salt Lake City, Utah, US |  | 
| 82 | Loss | 53–12–15 (2) | Young Peter Jackson | KO | 2 (?) | Dec 20, 1899 | Germania Hall, Seattle, Washington, US |  | 
| 81 | Draw | 53–11–15 (2) | Jim Sellars | PTS | 8 | Oct 20, 1899 | Sioux City A.C., Sioux City, Iowa, US |  | 
| 80 | Loss | 53–11–14 (2) | Con Jacobus | TKO | 4 (?) | Sep 18, 1899 | Woodland Park, Sioux City, Iowa, US |  | 
| 79 | Draw | 53–10–14 (2) | Jim Sellars | PTS | 10 | Sep 13, 1899 | Opera House, Sioux City, Iowa, US |  | 
| 78 | Loss | 53–10–13 (2) | Charley Holcombe | NWS | 6 | Feb 6, 1897 | Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 77 | Loss | 53–9–13 (2) | Andy Watson | PTS | 4 | Jan 16, 1897 | Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 76 | Draw | 53–8–13 (2) | Jack Ramsey | PTS | 20 | Mar 3, 1894 | Fort Collins, Colorado, US |  | 
| 75 | Loss | 53–8–12 (2) | Bobby Dobbs | KO | 19 (?) | Jan 30, 1893 | Armory, San Francisco, California, US | A fight to the finish | 
| 74 | Loss | 53–7–12 (2) | Joe King | KO | 36 (?) | Oct 21, 1892 | California A.C., San Francisco, California, US |  | 
| 73 | Win | 53–6–12 (2) | Tom Harrington | KO | 2 (?) | May 31, 1892 | Pacific A.C., San Francisco, California, US | Exact date uncertain | 
| 72 | Draw | 52–6–12 (2) | Jimmy Lawler | PTS | 10 | Apr 18, 1892 | California A.C., San Francisco, California, US | Exact date uncertain | 
| 71 | Win | 52–6–11 (2) | Ed Moehler | KO | 2 (?) | Apr 7, 1892 | San Francisco, California, US | Exact date uncertain | 
| 70 | Loss | 51–6–11 (2) | Hank Griffin | KO | 4 (?) | Apr 1, 1892 | Location unknown | Date uncertain | 
| 69 | Loss | 51–5–11 (2) | Charles Turner | KO | 19 | Feb 29, 1892 | Occidental A.C., San Francisco, California, US | A fight to the finish | 
| 68 | Loss | 51–4–11 (2) | Ed Binney | RTD | 25 (?) | Nov 30, 1891 | California A.C., San Francisco, California, US | Lost world colored middleweight title | 
| 67 | Win | 51–3–11 (2) | Paddy Gorman | KO | 4 (?) | Oct 26, 1891 | Pacific A.C., San Francisco, California, US |  | 
| 66 | ND | 50–3–11 (2) | Spike Trainor | ND | 4 | Sep 5, 1891 | Arion Hall, Great Falls, Montana, US |  | 
| 65 | Win | 50–3–11 (1) | George Gannon | KO | 3 (?) | Aug 23, 1891 | Falke's Garden, Butte, Montana, US |  | 
| 64 | Win | 49–3–11 (1) | Joe Ellingsworth | KO | 5 (?) | Jul 21, 1891 | Twin City A.C., Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 63 | Win | 48–3–11 (1) | Tom Murray | KO | 7 (?) | May 29, 1891 | Twin City A.C., Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 62 | Win | 47–3–11 (1) | Mike Sullivan | KO | 1 (?) | May 16, 1891 | Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 61 | Loss | 46–3–11 (1) | Jerry Heggerty | PTS | 5 | May 12, 1891 | Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 60 | Win | 46–2–11 (1) | Frank Lewis | TKO | 5 (6) | May 7, 1891 | Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 59 | ND | 45–2–11 (1) | Bob Fitzsimmons | ND | 4 | May 1, 1891 | Washington Rink, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 58 | Draw | 45–2–11 | Denny Kelliher | PTS | 10 | Feb 10, 1891 | Newmarket Theatre, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US | Retained Northwest middleweight title | 
| 57 | Win | 45–2–10 | Jim Hightower | KO | 3 (?) | Nov 20, 1890 | Omaha, Nebraska, US |  | 
| 56 | Win | 44–2–10 | Denny Kelliher | PTS | 20 | Nov 3, 1890 | Twin City A.C., Minneapolis, Missouri, US | Retained Northwest middleweight title | 
| 55 | Win | 43–2–10 | Jim Hightower | PTS | 8 | Sep 9, 1890 | Saint Joseph, Missouri, US |  | 
| 54 | Draw | 42–2–10 | Frank Lewis | PTS | 8 | Jun 27, 1890 | Saint Paul, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 53 | Win | 42–2–9 | Dick Moore | TKO | 4 (6) | May 23, 1890 | Olympic Theater, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US | Retained Northwest middleweight title | 
| 52 | Win | 41–2–9 | Dick Moore | KO | 7 (?) | Feb 3, 1890 | Minneapolis, Minnesota, US | Won vacant Northwest middleweight title | 
| 51 | Win | 40–2–9 | Ed Moehler | KO | 8 (?) | Dec 9, 1888 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 50 | Win | 39–2–9 | James Aster | KO | 1 (?) | Oct 5, 1888 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 49 | Draw | 38–2–9 | Charles Hadley | PTS | 8 | Aug 10, 1888 | Theatre Comique, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 48 | Draw | 38–2–8 | James Legger | PTS | 10 | Aug 3, 1888 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 47 | Win | 38–2–7 | J.P. Smith | KO | 4 (?) | Jul 14, 1888 | Lake City, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 46 | Win | 37–2–7 | Dick Haley | PTS | 4 | Jun 15, 1888 | Cominique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 45 | Win | 36–2–7 | J.P. Donner | PTS | 10 | Jun 1, 1888 | Theatre Comique, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 44 | Win | 35–2–7 | John Dwyer | KO | 2 (?) | May 25, 1888 | Theatre Comique, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 43 | Win | 34–2–7 | Charles Gleason | PTS | 6 | May 18, 1888 | Cominique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 42 | Win | 33–2–7 | Ed Harris | PTS | 4 | Apr 8, 1888 | Saint Paul, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 41 | Win | 32–2–7 | Hunter Briscoe | KO | 6 (8) | Mar 2, 1888 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 40 | Win | 31–2–7 | Ed Moehler | PTS | 8 | Dec 30, 1887 | Gary, Indiana, US |  | 
| 39 | Draw | 30–2–7 | Frank Taylor | PTS | 10 | Dec 10, 1887 | Ashland, Wisconsin, US |  | 
| 38 | Win | 30–2–6 | James Legger | DQ | 13 (15) | Nov 11, 1887 | Theatre Comique, Minneapolis, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 37 | Win | 29–2–6 | James Legger | TKO | 5 (10) | Nov 1, 1887 | Theatre Comique, Minneapolis, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 36 | Win | 28–2–6 | Paddy Norton | KO | 3 (?) | Sep 6, 1887 | Lake Calhoun, Minneapolis, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 35 | Win | 27–2–6 | OH Smith | PTS | 4 | Aug 5, 1887 | Washington Roller Rink, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 34 | Win | 26–2–6 | Tom Jackson | KO | 5 (?) | Jul 15, 1887 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 33 | Win | 25–2–6 | Frank Taylor | KO | 38 (?) | May 2, 1887 | Woods outside of Minneapolis, Minnesota, US | Won inaugural world colored middleweight title | 
| 32 | Win | 24–2–6 | Desperate Coon | TKO | 3 (4) | Apr 22, 1887 | Olympic Theater, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 31 | Win | 23–2–6 | Charles Hadley | PTS | 8 | Apr 15, 1887 | Olympic Theater, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 30 | Draw | 22–2–6 | Frank Taylor | PTS | 12 | Apr 1, 1887 | Olympic Theater, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 29 | Win | 22–2–5 | Charles Hadley | PTS | 8 | Mar 25, 1887 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 28 | Draw | 21–2–5 | Frank Taylor | PTS | 10 | Mar 18, 1887 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 27 | Win | 21–2–4 | Dan Sommers | KO | 4 (?) | Mar 11, 1887 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 26 | Win | 20–2–4 | Tom Devine | KO | 5 (5) | Mar 3, 1887 | Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 25 | Win | 19–2–4 | Will Young | KO | 2 (?) | Feb 27, 1887 | Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 24 | Win | 18–2–4 | Black Strap | KO | 4 (10) | Feb 18, 1887 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 23 | Win | 17–2–4 | Jim O'Brien | KO | 4 (?) | Feb 7, 1887 | Exposition Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 22 | Draw | 16–2–4 | Dan Manning | PTS | 10 | Jan 28, 1887 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 21 | Win | 16–2–3 | Frank Taylor | PTS | 15 | Jan 21, 1887 | Comique Theater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 20 | Win | 15–2–3 | Dan Sommers | KO | 3 (?) | Jan 7, 1887 | Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 19 | Win | 14–2–3 | George Gannon | KO | 11 (?) | Jan 3, 1887 | Cribbe Club Room, Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 18 | Loss | 13–2–3 | Frank Taylor | PTS | 10 | Dec 22, 1886 | Olympic Theater, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 17 | Win | 13–1–3 | Young McKay | KO | 4 (8) | Dec 21, 1886 | Saint Paul, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 16 | Win | 12–1–3 | Dan Sommers | TKO | 7 (?) | Dec 5, 1886 | Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 15 | Win | 11–1–3 | Black Strap | PTS | 4 | Dec 3, 1886 | Clarks Club, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 14 | Draw | 10–1–3 | Jim O'Brien | PTS | 4 | Dec 2, 1886 | Exposition Rink, Saint Paul, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 13 | Win | 10–1–2 | Cass Brown | PTS | 8 | Nov 14, 1886 | Minneapolis, Minnesota, US |  | 
| 12 | Win | 9–1–2 | Billy Young | KO | 9 (?) | Sep 27, 1886 | Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 11 | Win | 8–1–2 | Jack Murphy | KO | 3 (?) | Sep 7, 1886 | Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 10 | Win | 7–1–2 | Billy Young | KO | 9 (?) | Sep 6, 1886 | Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 9 | Loss | 6–1–2 | Joe Butler | PTS | 4 | Aug 7, 1886 | Clark's Club, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 8 | Win | 6–0–2 | Tom Henderson | KO | 3 (?) | Jul 3, 1886 | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 7 | Draw | 5–0–2 | Mike Highland | PTS | 4 | Jun 22, 1886 | Clark's Club, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 6 | Win | 5–0–1 | Charles Johnson | KO | 3 (4) | Jun 16, 1886 | Clark's Club, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 5 | Win | 4–0–1 | Bill Boughbly | KO | 3 (?) | Jun 11, 1886 | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 4 | Win | 3–0–1 | Bill Travers | KO | 1 (4) | Jun 4, 1886 | Clark's Club, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 3 | Win | 2–0–1 | Bill Davis | KO | 3 (4) | May 18, 1886 | Clark's Club, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 2 | Win | 1–0–1 | Tom Henderson | KO | 5 (?) | May 8, 1886 | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US |  | 
| 1 | Draw | 0–0–1 | Jack Burke | PTS | 4 | Mar 19, 1886 | Cincinnati, Ohio, US |  | 
|