| Incident |
Location |
Date |
Description |
Sources |
| John McCaffary | Kenosha | July 23, 1850 | Convicted of drowning his wife in a cistern, his execution was botched, leading to the abolition of capital punishment in Wisconsin |
| Little Lord Fauntleroy | Waukesha | 1921 | Unsolved murder of young boy found floating in a pond | |
| Arthur "Buddy" Schumacher | Wauwatosa | 1925 | Unsolved murder of 8-year-old boy; later the subject of the 2012 book Murder in Wauwatosa: The Mysterious Death of Buddy Schumacher | |
| Jack Zuta | Delafield | August 1, 1930 | Organized crime figure fatally shot at a roadhouse | |
| Sterling Hall bombing | Madison | August 24, 1970 | Bombing at University of Wisconsin as protest of connections with military research during Vietnam War, a physics researcher was killed and three others injured | |
| Murder of Lisa Ann French | Fond du Lac | October 31, 1973 | 9-year old girl murdered and sexually assaulted by neighbor while trick-or-treating alone | |
| Murder of Christine Schultz | Milwaukee | May 28, 1981 | Former Milwaukee police officer convicted for the murder of her husband's ex-wife; she escaped in 1990 in an episode that inspired the slogan "Run, Bambi, Run" | |
| Murder of Amber Creek | Burlington | 1997-02 | Teenager who ran away from a youth shelter; suspect convicted of her murder 34 years later | |
| Murder of Traci Hammerberg | Grafton | December 15, 1984 | 18-year-old murdered while walking home from a party; murderer identified 35 years later | |
| Murder of Susan Poupart | Lac du Flameau | May 20, 1990 | Unsolved murder of 29-year-old Native American woman | |
| Jesse Anderson | Milwaukee | April 21, 1992 | Convicted of murdering his wife Barbara Anderson; was then murdered along with Jeffrey Dahmer in prison by Christopher Scarver | |
| Murder of Alfred Kunz | Dane | March 4, 1998 | Unsolved murder of a Catholic priest found in church with his throat slit |
| Death of Julie Jensen | Pleasant Prairie | December 3, 1998 | Husband convicted of murdering his wife; conviction later overturned; notable for admission into evidence of a letter written by deceased expressing suspicion of husband's intentions | |
| Murder of Glenn Kopitske | Winnebago County | July 21, 2003 | Thrill killing of a bipolar 37-year-old man | |
Murder of Teresa Halbach (Steven Avery, Brendan Dassey) | Manitowoc County | October 31, 2005 | Photographer murdered by man who hired her to photograph a minivan, later the subject of the Netflix series Making a Murderer | |
| 2006 Weston High School shooting | Cazenovia | September 29, 2006 | Student fatally shot high school principal | |
| Murder of Cha Vang | Green Bay | 2007 | 30-year-old Hmong man shot and stabbed by James Nichols who had expressed racial animus to Hmong people | |
| Murder of Erika Hill | Fitchburg | 2007-02 | 15-year-old girl was victim of long term abuse and starvation, then beaten, stabbed and asphyxiated by mother | |
| Murder of Amy Yeary | Campbellsport | 2008-08 | 18-year-old woman murdered in 2008, body was unidentified for 13 years, aka "Fond du Lac County Jane Doe" | |
| Murder of Hussain Saeed Alnahdi | Menomonie | October 31, 2016 | 24-year-old student from Saudi Arabia beaten to death outside a pizzeria in downtown Menomonie | |
| Killing of Ee Lee | Milwaukee | September 19, 2020 | Woman raped and murdered by two teenage boys on video in front of nine other youths | |
| Murder of Shad Thyrion | Green Bay | February 21, 2022 | 24-year-old American man killed during sexual intercourse and then dismembered. | |
| Killing of Lily Peters | Chippewa Falls | April 22, 2022 | 10-year-old girl raped and murdered, her 14-year-old cousin was arrested and is being tried as an adult |
| John Pier Roemer | New Lisbon | June 3, 2022 | Juneau County judge fatally shot by a man convicted in his court six years earlier | |
| Death of Sade Robinson | Milwaukee | April 1, 2024 | 19-year-old woman killed and dismembered. | |