| State | Name | Hometown | Age | Local Title | Talent | Placement | Awards | Notes | 
|---|
|  Alabama | Abby Lynn Steverson | Smiths Station |  |  | Piano, "Maple Leaf Rag" | Top 10[2] |  |  | 
|  Alaska | Kaela Larson[3] | Willow | 15 | At-Large | Vocal |  |  | Previously America's National Jr. Sweetheart 2005[4] | 
|  Arizona | Brittany Mazur[5] | Tucson | 16 | At-Large | Vocal, "Adagio" |  |  | Contestant on season 10 of American Idol[5][6] 
 Top 5 at National Sweetheart 2012 pageant
 | 
|  Arkansas | Dorothy Shepard | Pine Bluff | 17 | Miss Teen South Arkansas | Tap Dance, "Hot Chocolate!" | 4th runner-up[2] |  |  | 
|  California | Summer Clark[7] | Elk Grove | 16 | Miss Teen Elk Grove | Drums, "Turn the Beat Around" |  |  |  | 
|  Colorado | Kelsi Johnston | Pueblo West | 16 |  | Piano/Vocal, "Someone Like You" |  |  |  | 
|  Connecticut | Melanie Sanches[8] | Prospect | 16 |  | Character Tap Dance |  |  | Former NFL cheerleader for the New England Patriots[8][9] | 
|  Delaware | Lauren Gagliardino[10] | Bear | 16 | Miss New Castle County's Outstanding Teen | Tap Dance |  |  |  | 
|  District of Columbia | Elizabeth Ann Payne | Washington, D.C. |  |  | Operatic Vocal |  |  |  | 
|  Florida | Sydney Keister[11] | Jacksonville | 17 | Miss Jacksonville's Outstanding Teen | Lyrical Jazz Dance, Disney's "Fantasmic" |  |  | 4th runner-up at Miss Florida 2013 pageant[citation needed] | 
|  Georgia | Lauren Edmonds[12] | Americus |  | Miss Heart of Georgia's Outstanding Teen | Ballet en Pointe, "I Run for Life" |  | Non-finalist Evening Wear/OSQ Award | 1st runner-up at Miss Georgia 2008 and 2013 pageants[13][14] 
 3rd runner-up at Miss Georgia 2012 pageant[15]
 
 Contestant at National Sweetheart 2008 pageant
 | 
|  Hawaii | Katrina Kem[16] | Wahiawa | 16 |  | Piano/Vocal, "Imagine" |  |  |  | 
|  Idaho | Genevieve Nutting[17] | Boise | 17 | At-Large | Classical Piano |  |  | Later Miss Idaho 2011[18] | 
|  Illinois | Campbell Hunt[19] | Marion |  | Miss John A. Logan's Outstanding Teen | Vocal, "God Help the Outcasts" |  |  |  | 
|  Indiana | Leanna Ross[20] | New Carlisle | 17 | Miss Hoosier Heartland's Outstanding Teen | Dance/Baton |  |  |  | 
|  Iowa | Erica Lester | Muscatine |  | Miss Scott County's Outstanding Teen | Lyrical Jazz Dance |  | Academic Scholarship Award |  | 
|  Kansas | Erica Mahan | Neosho Rapids | 17 | Miss Capital City's Outstanding Teen | Flute, "Can Can" |  |  |  | 
|  Kentucky | Alison Lovely[citation needed] | Sayerville | 16 | Miss Belle of the Bluegrass' Outstanding Teen | Vocal, "Blue Moon of Kentucky" |  |  |  | 
|  Louisiana | Jeremeka Bradley[21] | Bossier City | 16 | Miss Bossier City's Outstanding Teen | Vocal |  | Overall Interview Award 
 Spirit of America Award
 |  | 
|  Maine | Mallory Lavole | Madawaska | 16 |  | Piano |  |  |  | 
|  Maryland | Hannah Mollerick | Jessup |  | Miss Howard County's Outstanding Teen | Jazz en Pointe |  |  | Contestant at National Sweetheart 2010 pageant Later 4th runner-up at Miss Maryland 2010,[22] 2011,[23] and 2013[24] Later Top 10 at Miss Maryland 2012[22] | 
|  Massachusetts | Cherise Marie Leclerc | Hampden |  |  | Harp | Top 10[2] |  | Later 4th runner-up at Miss Massachusetts 2008 | 
|  Michigan | Nina Davuluri[25] | St. Joseph | 16 | Miss Southwest Michigan's Outstanding Teen | Modern Classical Indian Dance | 1st runner-up[2] | Preliminary Evening Wear/OSQ Award | Later Miss New York 2013[26] Crowned Miss America 2014[27]
 | 
|  Minnesota | Natalie Davis | Dassel |  |  | Vocal |  | Academic Achievement Award | Contestant at National Sweetheart 2009 pageant 
 Later Miss Minnesota 2011[28]
 | 
|  Mississippi | Kasey Wilder[29] | Pontotoc |  | Miss Pontotoc's Outstanding Teen | Vocal, "New York State of Mind" |  |  |  | 
|  Missouri | Melanie Collier[30] | Kirksville |  | Miss Kirksville's Outstanding Teen | Lyrical Jazz Dance |  |  |  | 
|  Montana | Holly Matz[31] | Missoula | 16 |  | Jump Rope Routine |  |  | Later 1st runner-up at Miss Montana 2009[32] | 
|  Nebraska | Sharla Schreiber[33] | Columbus | 16 |  | Jazz/Flag |  |  |  | 
|  Nevada | Jordan Bowler | Mesquite |  |  | Freestyle Taekwondo Routine, "Feel the Beat" |  |  |  | 
|  New Hampshire | Janine Mitchell[34] | Derry | 17 |  | Lyrical Jazz Dance, "Man in the Mirror" |  |  |  | 
|  New Jersey | Lindsey Petrosh[35] | Egg Harbor City | 17 |  | Vocal |  |  | Later Miss New Jersey 2012[36] | 
|  New Mexico | Ellen Striepeke | Silver City |  |  | Tap Dance |  |  |  | 
|  New York | Maria DeSantis[37] | Staten Island | 17 | Miss Staten Island's Outstanding Teen | Classical Vocal | Winner[2] | Preliminary Talent Award | 3rd runner-up at Miss New York 2012 pageant 
 Top 10 at National Sweetheart 2012 pageant
 | 
|  North Carolina | Ciara Newman[38] | Hendersonville |  | Miss Hendersonville's Outstanding Teen | Lyrical Dance |  |  |  | 
|  North Dakota | Rachel Douts[39] | Powers Lake |  |  | Vocal, "One Moment in Time" |  |  |  | 
|  Ohio | Kelsey Ballew | Chillicothe | 16 |  | Vocal |  |  |  | 
|  Oklahoma | Molly Colvard | Elm Grove | 16 | Miss Oklahoma City University's Outstanding Teen | Vocal | Top 10[2] |  | Sister of Chelsea Colvard, Miss Oklahoma Teen USA 2009[citation needed] | 
|  Oregon | Kylee Willard | Grants Pass | 17 | Miss Josephine County's Outstanding Teen | Latin/Jazz Dance to a Mix of "Represent Cuba/Do You Only Wanna Dance?" |  |  |  | 
|  Pennsylvania | Tawni Darby[40] | Hermitage | 15 | Miss Moraine State's Outstanding Teen | Lyrical Dance |  | Non-finalist Talent Award | Founder of Miss America's Outstanding Teen Teens in Training Camp[40] | 
|  Rhode Island | Lindsay Rogers[citation needed] | Lincoln | 17 |  | Vocal |  |  |  | 
|  South Carolina | Maggie Hill[41] | Gilbert | 17 | Miss Lexington Teen | Classical Vocal, "Think of Me" from Phantom of the Opera | Top 10[2] | Preliminary Talent Award |  | 
|  South Dakota | Aja Kessler[42] | Rapid City | 17 |  | Ballet en Pointe, "Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy" |  |  | Older half-sister of Miss South Dakota's Outstanding Teen 2013, Nina Mesteth[43] 2nd runner-up at Miss South Dakota 2009 pageant[44] Contestant at National Sweetheart 2009 pageant  | 
|  Tennessee | Leah Beth Bolton[45] | Jackson |  |  | Tap Dance | 3rd runner-up[46] | Preliminary Lifestyle & Fitness Award | 2nd runner-up at the Miss Tennessee Teen USA 2008 pageant[47] | 
|  Texas | Kendall Morris[citation needed] | Ennis | 15 | Miss Teen Southlake | Classical Piano, "Chopsticks" |  | Preliminary Evening Wear/OSQ Award 
 Preliminary Lifestyle & Fitness Award
 | Later Miss Texas 2011[48] Top 10 at Miss America 2012 pageant[49]
 | 
|  Utah | Tasha Smedley[50] | Syracuse |  |  | Modern Lyrical Dance |  |  | Later Miss Utah Teen USA 2009[51] Top 15 at Miss Teen USA 2009 pageant[51]
 
 NFL cheerleader for the Dallas Cowboys in 2016 to 2018[52][53]
 | 
|  Vermont | Heather Bartlett[54] | Jericho |  |  | Classical Vocal, "Laughing Song" |  |  |  | 
|  Virginia | Brittany Young[55] | Mechanicsville | 17 |  | Classical Vocal | 2nd runner-up[2] |  | Daughter of Miss Virginia 1982, Beverly Cooke[55][56] 
 4th runner-up at Miss Virginia 2011 pageant[57]
 | 
|  Virgin Islands | Esconica Veira | Saint Thomas |  |  | Hip Hop Dance |  |  | Later represented the Virgin Islands at the Miss World 2011 pageant and placed in the Top 15[58] 
 4th runner-up at Miss Supranational 2013 pageant
 
 Represented the Virgin Islands at Miss Earth 2014 pageant[59]
 Later Miss US Virgin Islands 2017 | 
|  Washington | Stefanie Range[60] | Auburn | 13 | Miss Lakeland Hills' Outstanding Teen | Vocal, "Shy" |  |  |  | 
|  West Virginia | Kaitlin Gates[61] | Bridgeport | 14 | Miss Teen Appalachia | Vocal |  |  | 2nd runner-up at Miss West Virginia Teen USA 2008 pageant[62] 
 Later Miss West Virginia 2012[63]
 | 
|  Wisconsin | Allie Rick[64] | Greendale | 15 | At-Large | Lyrical Dance, "Here Comes the Sun" | Top 10[64] |  |  | 
|  Wyoming | Codie Lee Ann Murphy | Sheridan | 17 | Miss Sheridan's Outstanding Teen | Japanese Fan Dance |  |  |  |