Question...?
2022 song by Taylor Swift From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
"Question...?" is a song by the American singer-songwriter Taylor Swift from her tenth studio album, Midnights (2022). Written and produced by Swift and Jack Antonoff, it is a minimalist electropop and synth-pop track that incorporates synth tones and sharp drum machine beats. The song contains a vocal sample of Swift's 2014 track "Out of the Woods". In the lyrics, Swift's narrator confronts an ex-lover with questions regarding their past behaviors and what could have happened differently.
| "Question...?" | |
|---|---|
| |
| Promotional single by Taylor Swift | |
| from the album Midnights | |
| Released | October 25, 2022 |
| Studio |
|
| Genre | |
| Length | 3:30 |
| Label | Republic |
| Songwriter(s) |
|
| Producer(s) |
|
| Lyric video | |
| "Question...?" on YouTube | |
"Question...?" was released for limited-time download exclusively via Swift's website on October 25, 2022. In reviews of Midnights, critics who picked the track as an album highlight praised its lyrical details and production. The song peaked at number 11 on the Billboard Global 200 and within the top 10 on charts of Canada, the Philippines, Singapore, and the US. It received certifications in Australia, Canada, and the UK. Swift performed "Question...?" twice on her sixth concert tour, the Eras Tour.
Background and release
Summarize
Perspective
Taylor Swift announced her tenth original studio album, Midnights, at the 2022 MTV Video Music Awards on August 28;[1] its title and cover artwork were released shortly after via social media.[2] She conceived Midnights as a collection of songs about her nocturnal ruminations, detailing a wide range of emotions such as regret, lust, nostalgia, contentment, and self-loathing.[3] The standard album was produced by Swift and Jack Antonoff, as a result of the two experimenting with music while their partners were both shooting for a film in Panama.[3]
The album's track listing was revealed via a thirteen-episode video series called Midnights Mayhem with Me on the platform TikTok, where each video contained the title of one track at a time.[4] Track seven's title, "Question...?", was revealed in the September 26, 2022, episode.[5] Republic Records released Midnights on October 21, 2022,[6] and "Question...?" was released exclusively onto Swift's official website for limited-time download on October 25.[7] The instrumental version was released two days later.[8][9] Swift performed "Question...?" twice on her sixth concert tour, the Eras Tour. She sang an acoustic version on May 20, 2023, in Foxborough, Massachusetts,[10] and as part of a mashup with "The Archer" on July 4, 2024, in Amsterdam, the Netherlands.[11]
"Question...?" peaked at number 11 on the Billboard Global 200.[12] In the US, the song debuted and peaked at number seven on the Billboard Hot 100. It was one of the Midnights tracks that made Swift the first artist to occupy the top 10 of the Hot 100 the same week, and the woman with the most top 10 entries (40), exceeding Madonna (38).[13][14] On the Digital Songs chart, it became Swift's record-extending 24th number-one song, propelled by the limited-time downloads.[15][16] "Question...?" peaked in the top 10 of charts in Canada,[17] the Philippines,[18] Singapore,[19] and Malaysia;[20] and in the top 20 in Australia,[21] Vietnam,[22] Iceland,[23] and Portugal.[24] The track was certified silver in the UK,[25] gold in Brazil and Canada,[26][27] and platinum in Australia.[28]
Production and music
Summarize
Perspective
Swift wrote and produced "Question...?" with Antonoff, who programmed the track and recorded it at Rough Customer Studio, Brooklyn, and Electric Lady Studios, New York City. Antonoff played the Juno 6 and the Mellotron, and he provided background vocals. The track features various drum players: Dominik Rivinius, whose performance was recorded by Ken Lewis at Neon Wave Studio, Pirmasens, Germany; Evan Smith, who recorded his performance at Pleasure Hill Recording, Portland, Maine; and Sean Hutchinson, who recorded his performance at Hutchinson Sound, Brooklyn. Serban Ghenea, assisted by Bryce Bordone, mixed "Question...?" at MixStar Studio, Virginia Beach, Virginia, and Randy Merrill mastered it at Sterling Sound, Edgewater, New Jersey.[29]
"Question...?" is 3 minutes and 30 seconds long.[30] It is a minimalist electropop[31] and synth-pop song[32] whose verses are driven by subdued synths and drum machine beats[33] that critics describe as sharp[34] and crisp.[31] From the second refrain, the beats become louder.[33] The final refrain contains sounds of a crowd cheering, credited to Antonoff, Antonoff's sister Rachel, Swift's brother Austin, and the actor Dylan O'Brien.[35][36] The track begins with a vocal sample of the lyric "I remember", taken from the track "Out of the Woods" from Swift's 2014 album 1989.[37] This sample usage won "Favorite Use of a Sample" at the 2023 iHeartRadio Music Awards.[38]
Lyrics and interpretations
Summarize
Perspective
In "Question...?", Swift's narrator ruminates on a relationship that ended bitterly.[31][39] The song depicts the narrator as a "good girl" and her ex-lover as a "sad boy"; they met in a big city and both made bad decisions.[40][41] In the refrain, the narrator confronts the ex-lover with multiple questions about their past behaviors, such as not staying the night with her and not fighting hard enough to keep her when he still had a chance ("Did you leave her house in the middle of the night? Did you wish you'd put up more of a fight when she said it was too much?").[31][42] She ultimately asks the ex-lover if he is still attracted to her ("Do you wish you could still touch her?").[31][42] According to Rob Sheffield of Rolling Stone, Swift's narrator "wishes she didn't already know the answers".[43] Towards the conclusion, the narrator mocks her ex-lover's new girlfriend ("And what's that that I heard, that you're still with her, that's nice/ I'm sure that's what's suitable/ And right"),[39] with Swift's vocals featuring heavier digital manipulation and the production becoming more intense with louder beats, pronounced synth tones, and dense echoing effects, which symbolize how the memories are distorted in the narrator's mind.[44]
There were comparisons of the track's production and theme to those of Swift's past songs. Several reviews thought that the sound of "Question...?" evoked the styles of tracks from 1989 such as "Out of the Woods"[33] and "Blank Space".[40] Carl Wilson from Slate wrote that the resemblance to "Blank Space" is in how Swift interpolates her "descending-scale" cadence from its bridge.[37] The late-night encounters with a love interest are similar to those portrayed in the 1989 songs "Style", "All You Had to Do Was Stay", and "How You Get the Girl", and the lyric mentioning the couple kissing "in a crowded room" references "Dress" from the album Reputation (2017).[45] In Billboard, Becky Kaminsky wrote that "Question...?" resembles Reputation by portraying a version of Swift that "isn't afraid to hold back".[46] According to the English-language scholar Maggie Laurel Boyd, "Question...?" revisits the memories mentioned in "Out of the Woods", but the narrator is more upfront: she asserts that she still remembers what happened and discerns new meanings in old stories.[47]
Several critics analyzed the lyrics with regards to women's psychology in dating and romance. Annie Zaleski summed up the narrative as a demand for closure from an ex-lover who had moved on, and she wrote that the dynamic build-up towards the end represented the narrator's jealousy towards her ex-lover's new love and urgent needs for clear answers.[31] Alejandra Gularte of Vulture thought that the track was relatable for those who have an anxious attachment.[48] NPR's Ann Powers cited the lyrics, "Did you ever have someone kiss you in a crowded room/ And every single one of your friends was making fun of you/ But 15 seconds later they were clapping too?", as an example that portrays romantic persuasion and betrayal. For Powers, the said lines encapsulate how women's anxiety and uncertainty in love can be exacerbated by others' perceptions of and desires for them.[49]
Critical reception
Summarize
Perspective
Positive reviews of "Question...?" mostly praised its lyricism. Liam E Semler, a professor in early modern English literature, considered it a complex track worthy of detailed analysis.[50] Jon Caramanica of The New York Times and Alexis Petridis of The Guardian selected the song as one of the better album tracks lyrically;[51] the latter complimented its "subtle, brilliant touches", particularly the moment when the lyrics "simultaneously speed up their rhyme and stop rhyming" to depict a drunken conversation.[52][53] Zaleski and Powers regarded "Question...?" as a relatable song;[31] the latter hailed it as "the kind of story song only Swift can write" for capturing the painful emotional sentiments experienced by many women with the details "so acutely that it stings".[49] Caramanica and Powers said that the track displays Swift's tartness, a quality that the latter thought to evoke the poet Dorothy Parker.[49][51] Wilson and The Atlantic's Spencer Kornhaber were moved by the nostalgia and wistfulness of the storytelling,[37][54] and The A.V. Club's Saloni Gajjar wrote that it contains "classic Swift charm and potent use of metaphors".[55]
A few critics also praised the production. Bobby Olivier from Spin described the track as a "banger" that has a radio hit potential,[32] and Ellen Johnson of Paste considered the song meticulously produced, with a more nuanced and restrained production compared to common pop music.[56] In a less welcoming review, Craig Jenkins from Vulture deemed the refrain "cloying" that blemishes an otherwise fine album.[41] Placing "Question...?" last in his ranking of all 13 Midnights tracks, Jason Lipshutz of Billboard wrote that while it "doesn't fully congeal, [... it] boasts some fascinating tidbits to pore over".[57]
Personnel
Credits are adapted from the liner notes of Midnights.[29]
- Taylor Swift – vocals, songwriter, producer
- Jack Antonoff – songwriter, producer, programming, percussion, Juno 6, Mellotron, background vocals, recording, crowd applause
- Dominik Rivinius – drums
- Evan Smith – drums
- Sean Hutchinson – drums, percussion
- Rachel Antonoff – crowd applause
- Austin Swift – crowd applause
- Dylan O'Brien – crowd applause
- Megan Searl – assistant engineer
- John Sher – assistant engineer
- John Rooney – assistant engineer
- Serban Ghenea – mix engineer
- Bryce Bordone – assistant mix engineer
- Randy Merrill – mastering engineer
- Laura Sisk – recording
- David Hart – recording
- Ken Lewis – recording
Charts
| Chart (2022–2023) | Peak position |
|---|---|
| Australia (ARIA)[21] | 11 |
| Canada (Canadian Hot 100)[17] | 10 |
| Czech Republic (Singles Digitál Top 100)[58] | 40 |
| France (SNEP)[59] | 139 |
| Global 200 (Billboard)[12] | 11 |
| Greece International (IFPI)[60] | 17 |
| Iceland (Tónlistinn)[23] | 20 |
| Ireland (Billboard)[61] | 10 |
| Lithuania (AGATA)[62] | 36 |
| Malaysia (Billboard)[63] | 14 |
| Malaysia International (RIM)[20] | 8 |
| Philippines (Billboard)[18] | 7 |
| Portugal (AFP)[24] | 21 |
| Singapore (RIAS)[19] | 7 |
| Slovakia (Singles Digitál Top 100)[64] | 46 |
| Spain (PROMUSICAE)[65] | 62 |
| Sweden (Sverigetopplistan)[66] | 42 |
| Swiss Streaming (Schweizer Hitparade)[67] | 44 |
| UK (Billboard)[68] | 12 |
| UK Audio Streaming (OCC)[69] | 12 |
| UK Singles Downloads (OCC)[70] | 96 |
| US Billboard Hot 100[14] | 7 |
| Vietnam (Vietnam Hot 100)[22] | 15 |
Certifications
| Region | Certification | Certified units/sales |
|---|---|---|
| Australia (ARIA)[28] | Platinum | 70,000‡ |
| Brazil (Pro-Música Brasil)[26] | Gold | 20,000‡ |
| Canada (Music Canada)[27] | Gold | 40,000‡ |
| New Zealand (RMNZ)[71] | Gold | 15,000‡ |
| United Kingdom (BPI)[25] | Silver | 200,000‡ |
|
‡ Sales+streaming figures based on certification alone. | ||
Release history
| Region | Date | Format | Version | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| United States | October 25, 2022 | Digital download | Original | [7] |
| October 27, 2022 | Instrumental | [72] |
See also
References
Wikiwand - on
Seamless Wikipedia browsing. On steroids.