Tell Me Why (John Holt song)

"Tell Me Why" is a song by Jamaican reggae singer John Holt, released as the B-side to his UK top-ten single "Help Me Make It Through the Night" in 1974. It was covered by Musical Youth in 1983, becoming a top-40 hit.^[2]

"Tell Me Why"
Single by Musical Youth
from the album Different Style!
B-side	"Reason"
Released	1 July 1983 (1983-07-01)[1]
Recorded	1983
Genre	Reggae reggae-pop
Length	3:14 6:17 (12" version)
Label	MCA
Songwriter(s)	John Holt
Producer(s)	Peter Collins
Musical Youth singles chronology
"Heartbreaker" (1983) "Tell Me Why" (1983) "Unconditional Love" (1983)

Musical Youth version

Releases

"Tell Me Why" was released as a single at the beginning of July 1983 with the B-side "Reason", written by Musical Youth's Dennis Seaton and Freddie "Junior" Waite. Whereas the A-side was produced by Peter Collins, "Reason" was produced by Toney Owens.^[3] There were two versions of the 12-inch singles released. The first features a remix of "Tell Me Why" by Willi Morrison and Ian Guenther as well as an extended version of "Reason". The second features an additional track, a remix of "Heartbreaker", which had been released as the band's previous single. This 12"-inch single was only released in Europe, where "Heartbreaker" had not been released as a single.^[4]

Reception

Reviewing for Record Mirror, Paul Sexton wrote "It's not bad, of course, it's not bad, but now that we know what they look like, it's all down to the records and this John Holt number, as jiggled about by our short friends, has few distinguishing marks. Pity, because the idea of the group is still fun, but they need something to replace novelty value".^[5] Dave Rimmer for Smash Hits described it as "very jolly and jolly accomplished version... I'm glad they've got away from those vague "youth of today" -style clichés, the toasting is excellent and some of the percussion noises (the work of producer Peter Collins?) are particularly good fun".^[6]

Track listings

7": MCA / YOU 5

1. "Tell Me Why" – 3:14
2. "Reason" – 3:28

12": MCA / YOUT 5

1. "Tell Me Why" (Special US Remix) – 6:17
2. "Reason" (Extended Version) – 6:50

12": MCA / 600 962-213

1. "Tell Me Why" (Special US Remix) – 6:17
2. "Reason" (Extended Version) – 6:50
3. "Heartbreaker" (Special Dance Mix) – 5:36

Charts

Chart (1983)	Peak position
Belgium (Ultratop 50 Flanders)[7]	35
Ireland (IRMA)[8]	20
Netherlands (Dutch Top 40)[9]	26
Netherlands (Single Top 100)[10]	31
UK Singles (OCC)[2]	33