When the Past Was Around

When the Past Was Around is a 2020 point-and-click adventure video game developed by Mojiken Studio and published by Toge Productions. The game was released on September 22, 2020, for Windows. It was released on Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, and Xbox One in December 2020, then on Android and iOS in March 2022.

When the Past Was Around
Developer(s)	Mojiken Studio
Publisher(s)	Toge Productions Chorus Worldwide
Artist(s)	Brigitta Rena
Composer(s)	Masadito "Ittou" Bachtiar
Platform(s)	Windows Nintendo Switch Playstation 4 Xbox One Android iOS
Release	Windows September 22, 2020 Nintendo Switch December 16, 2020 PlayStation 4 December 17, 2020 Xbox One December 18, 2020 Android, iOS March 14, 2022
Genre(s)	Escape room
Mode(s)	Single-player

The game explores the relationship between a woman Eda and her lover, an anthropomorphic owl. It does not use any dialogue or text to allow open interpretations and incorporates music to its narrative and puzzles. Reviewers praised the game for its hand-drawn art style, emotional story, and its openness to interpretation. When the Past Was Around won the Best Visual Art award at the 2019 SEA Game Awards.

Gameplay

When the Past Was Around is an adventure point-and-click game and puzzle game.^[1][2] The player progresses in the game through solving escape-room-style puzzles, which take place in rooms and other locations shown from the side in a two-dimensional perspective. The player has to solve a number of puzzles related to daily activities such as doing laundry or drinking tea to proceed to the next location.^[3][4] To explore the current location, the player can move a cursor to the left and right of the screen. The cursor changes depending on whether the player can interact with the object. There is also a basic inventory; the player can drag an object from the inventory onto the screen to use it. A hint button also shows possible objects the player can interact with.^[4]

The game autosaves at the end of every chapter, as it is not possible to save progress between chapters.^[4] The only text in the game are terms for objects. The game only uses pictures and symbols to assist the player in gameplay.^[4][5] In one puzzle, the player has to refer to clues of numbers and symbols to play a melody in a piano. It is also described as a music game since some puzzles are based around music and require the player to find notes and complete melodies.^[4][6]

Plot

Development and release

When the Past Was Around was developed by Mojiken Studio and published by Toge Productions, which are both based in Indonesia. The game was created and illustrated by Indonesian illustrator and developer Brigatta Rena, who created the game as a love story that was relatable yet mysterious. It was made without any dialogue for players to loosely interpret her life experiences, which the game was based on. The development team had the challenge of having a unified view of the story from the game's absence of dialogue, as each member had a different interpretation of Eda and the owl's story. The team eventually agreed to the game's story details through "some trial and error", Rena said. Rena's hand-drawn scenes in the game were inspired from several manga and video games such as The Ancient Magus' Bride and Florence.^[5][7] Rena would join the narrative development team of A Space for the Unbound.^[7]

The game was released for Windows on September 22, 2020.^[8][9] Release of the game in consoles within the year was first announced in May 2020.^[10] In November, video game publisher Chorus Worldwide announced a release for PlayStation 4, Xbox One, and Nintendo Switch in December 2020 by publisher Chorus Worldwide was announced in November 2020.^[11] The game was published on the platforms from December 16 to 18, 2020.^[12][13][14] A mobile version of the game was announced in September 2021.^[15] It was released on iOS and Android on March 14, 2022.^[16][17]

Reception

Reception

Aggregate score

Aggregator	Score
Metacritic	(NS) 79/100[18] (PC) 77/100[19] (PS4) 78/100[20] (Xbox One) 73/100[21]

Review scores

Publication	Score
Eurogamer	7/10[22]
Gamezebo	70/100
Nintendo Life	[23]
Push Square	[1]

When the Past Was Around received "generally positive" reviews according to review aggregate site Metacritic^[24] and won the Best Visual Art award in the 2019 SEA Game Awards.^[2]

Reviewers gave positive reception on the game's hand-drawn visuals and sound.^{[5] [23][22]} Nintendo Life's Stuart Gipp compared the art style to a children's book, and noted that the game's use of autumnal colors prevented it from being excessively cute "or esoteric for the sake of it"^[23] Critics also praised the sound effects and the piano and string-heavy soundtrack, which emulated "authentic, intimate spaces" and a "comfortable, inquisitive tone that immediately puts you at ease", Katherine Castle from Rock Paper Shotgun would write.^[25] The lack of dialogue allowed the player to immerse in the soundtrack's piano and violin for Famitsu's "Amemiya".^[14]

Reviewers saw the point-and-click gameplay as "pretty standard"^[26] and consisting of "fairly rudimentary puzzles".^[26][27] Most of the game's puzzles, which eventually become sophisticated as the game progresses, remained straightforward.^[25] Most of the gameplay felt rote or underwhelming for Gamezebo's Maria Alexander. Alexander was also disappointed that gameplay coincided with the characters' emotions and narrative in only a few occasions, which made the game "never feel like a complete experience".^[27] Some reviewers also criticized the lack of an autosave feature between chapters.^[4] Reviewers finished the game within one to three hours.^[4] The game was brief and thus had an unrealized potential for Push Square's Graham Banks.^[1] Melanie Blagg of Adventure Gamers informed experienced players that they may not find the puzzles challenging, but recommended the game for its visuals, music, and emotional story.^[4]

Nintendo Life's Stuart Gipp calls the game a "pretty straightforward tale of grief and loss", although its "dreamy and [...] vague presentation" allowed any open interpretation. They also commended the game's possibility for open interpretation despite its rigid structure and linear narrative.^[23] Reviewers saw the scenes of the game disjointed, but become clearer as the game progresses as "touching, bittersweet experience".^[5][28] When The Past Was Around "hits your emotions with all the feels" despite its "bright and breezy art style", Castle wrote.^[25]